Public Comment: Who Are The Taliban Really? Print E-mail
Friday, 01 May 2009
287763_beauty_of_writing.jpgThere is a huge gap between reinterpreting the texts of quranic scriptures (something that runs against fiqh or islamic jurisprudence), and only attempting to highlight the humanistic values abundant in islam, to face the western critics. The first is totally inconceivable, as it runs against the reasoning behind the message of islam itself,that God has preserved through the original script and the sunna of the prophet (Peace be upon him), added to them the ijtihad of the scholars. The second point is quite timely and runs with sincere attempts by muslims to purify and publicize their religion, as it actually is, and not as often negatively depicted socially and politically.
But ask yourself why, in a world where Islam is the fastest growing religion, with people from a multitude of backgrounds reverting to Islam in their droves, if Jews and Christians leave their reinterpreted and distorted religions and seek refuge in one that is preserved in its pristine truth, why should Muslims make their religion like the one that these people flee? Does that make any sense?

The reason how a religion of peace has managed to gain a reputation for being a religion of war and terror is down to the way the Islamic scriptures are misinterpreted to suit perverted agendas. Words and phrases that are often repeated in the media have been misconstrued by individuals to give incorrect meanings. The deliberate blur between jihad and acts of terror has been a phenomenon that has resulted from those unqualified in the science of Sacred Law. Since the end of the Sunni Ottoman Caliphate in 1924, the Muslim world has been fragmented. The loss of unification created many difficulties from
which Muslims are still trying to recover. For one thing, it has seen the loss of the promulgation of traditional Islam, which has now given way to individuals claiming the right to "reinterpret" Islamic texts (Ijtihad) to grant them legitimacy in their own ideas (bida or innovation). This has seen a tendency toward ambiguity and the careless use of many important terms. Traditional Islam in contrast is related to the notion of orthodoxy, clarity and authority; to continuity and consistency in the transmission of the truth. It places its reliance upon classical scholarship as exemplified in the four schools of Islamic jurisprudence. Within this tradition of Islam, a true Islamic landscape emerges, encompassing the richness of scholarly tradition and its illuminating contribution to the advancement of civilisation.

On the topic of treatment of women, and stereotyping, ponder the verse from the Glorious Quran that says, "O you who believe! If a rebellious evil person comes to you with a news, verify it, lest you harm people in ignorance, and afterwards you become regretful to what you have done." [Al-Hujurat 49:6]. Allow me to take you back once more when after the Russians retreated from Afghanistan during the Russian occupation, on the other side, the American government, the British government, the French, the Chinese, and all of the rest, supported the counter-revolutionaries called the Mujahideen; These groups subsequently dispersed into Afghanistan. All of them had different ideologies, and a lot of weapons. Instead of having a single administration, they fought in Afghanistan. The destruction that they brought was worse than the destruction the Russians brought. 63,000 people were only killed in the capital, Kabul. Another million people migrated because of this lawlessness.

Seeing this destruction and lawlessness, a group of students called the Taliban, started a movement called the Movement of Students. It first started in a village in the southern province of Afghanistan, called Kandahar. It happened when a war-lord, or a commander abducted two minor girls and violated them. The parents of those girls went to a school and asked the teacher of the school to help them. The teacher of that school, along with a sizeable number of students, finding only 16 guns, went and attacked the base of that commander. After releasing those two girls, they hanged that commander, and so many of his people were also hanged. This story was told everywhere. BBC and other news networks also quoted this story. Hearing the story, many other students joined this movement and started disarming the rest of the warlords. This same students movement now controls over 95% of the country including its capital. Only a bunch of those warlords are remaining in the northern corridor of Afghanistan.

These warlords are the ones that are the "bad" apples and have nothing to do with Islam. The "Real" Taliban that I'm talking about, after coming into control, actually eliminated kidnappings, rapes, prostitution, robberies, and murders committed by bandits and dacoits, that were rampant in Afghanistan in the years after the Russians retreated. When the Taliban took control, all brothels in Kabul were closed and the bandits fled to neighboring countries for refuge (i.e. Pakistan, Iran etc). Women were given their rights back as per the Glorious Quran. Afghans were now free to travel even at night.

Thanks to the Student Movement i.e. Taliban, there now exists strict Islamic shariah in Afghanistan. They have closed cinemas, prohibited photography of people, banned gambling, prostitution, etc. They "enforce" morality on their people and totally reject any form of westernism and secularism, which they perceive as corruption and running contrary to their way of living i.e. the "true" Islam. Obviously, due to the existing occupation, the Afghan infrastructure is almost completely destroyed from war. The brave warriors of the Student Movement are now fighting to defend their country, its people, dignity, respect and honour. The only thing remaining is for God to grant them victory over their enemies. Peace.

Ahmed



Reddit!Del.icio.us!Facebook!

Readers have left 10 comments.
Mazhar:

How can the Taliban have been following the Sunnah of the Prophet? They pursued a strict ‘anti-modern’ agenda and never allowed anyone to question their extreme interpretation of the Koran.

I would like to repeat a few points I have made in an earlier comment about the Taliban (continuing my disagreement with Ahmed.) The fact is that the Taliban were an un-Islamic regime. They were brutal fanatics who established one of the most barbaric governments in the world. Their prevention of girls’ education was indeed prevalent and without reason. All women had to wear the niqab and could do little without the permission of their ‘guardians’. These were laws with no basis in Islam

The Afghans were joyous to be liberated from this regime and this is one area of foreign policy where Britain and America do deserve praise. I don’t overlook the bloodshed that ensued with the invasion of Afghanistan but they did displace the Taliban - who clearly lacked Islamic compassion, mercy and commitment to humanity. We now see the foundation grounds for democracy and human rights in that country. Furthermore, if the Taliban were following a true Islam why were Muslims around the world condemning what they were doing to their country? They did not adhere to mainstream Muslim scholarship and this was demonstrated in their vile treatment of women, Sufi Muslims, Shia Muslims and non-Muslims. The idea that the Afghan people would like to live without the advancement of the freedom and democracy they now have is definitely false. I hope the Taliban never return and I hope President Obama’s revised Afghanistan strategy is successful.
(1) 2009-05-01 05:09:04
Utter crap:

More bull**** extolling the virtues of those who hate everyone who is not Pashtun, not their intolerant brand of Sunni, those who are of the wrong gender and those who are not Muslims to follow on MPAC?
(2) 2009-05-01 16:32:46
Haseeb:

How can the Taliban have been following the Sunnah of the Prophet? They pursued a strict ‘anti-modern’ agenda and never allowed anyone to question their extreme interpretation of the Koran.

I would like to repeat a few points I have made in an earlier comment about the Taliban (continuing my disagreement with Ahmed.) The fact is that the Taliban were an un-Islamic regime. They were brutal fanatics who established one of the most barbaric governments in the world. Their prevention of girls’ education was indeed prevalent and without reason. All women had to wear the niqab and could do little without the permission of their ‘guardians’. These were laws with no basis in Islam

The Afghans were joyous to be liberated from this regime and this is one area of foreign policy where Britain and America do deserve praise. I don’t overlook the bloodshed that ensued with the invasion of Afghanistan but they did displace the Taliban - who clearly lacked Islamic compassion, mercy and commitment to humanity. We now see the foundation grounds for democracy and human rights in that country. Furthermore, if the Taliban were following a true Islam why were Muslims around the world condemning what they were doing to their country? They did not adhere to mainstream Muslim scholarship and this was demonstrated in their vile treatment of women, Sufi Muslims, Shia Muslims and non-Muslims. The idea that the Afghan people would like to live without the advancement of the freedom and democracy they now have is definitely false. I hope the Taliban never return and I hope President Obama’s revised Afghanistan strategy is successful.
— Mazhar


This comment is a typical reductio ad absurd argument that does not demonstrate any understanding of the reality, or even history of Afghanistan, or the development of the Taliban.

The Taliban arose at a time when there was widespread civil war and unrest in Afghanistan, where the various murderous warlords of the 'Northern Allianc' and other gangsters were busy slaughtering each other, after the withdrawal of the Soviets in 1989, not to mention instigating terrible atrocities against women (they were infamous for rape and dishonouring women), into this mess the Taliban stepped in defeating these rabid factions and implementing some order, they applied a strictly orthodox implementation of Shariah, which some may disagree with certain aspects but are valid opinions within the Islamic framework..they actually sought to protect women from the abuses that they had previously suffered under the warlords..as for girls schools, much of the syllabus prior to the Taliban period was based Communist texts from the soviet 1979-89 era, as such the Taliban wanted to Islamicise learning, and thereby many schools girls (and boys) were shut down...the Taliban did not really have the infrastructure to develop a new syllabus and were still engaged in war with the NA, so they were not reopened, despite individual schools being allowed to operate.

Far from being 'joyous', since 2001 Afghanistan has become split along ethnic lines with Tajik/Uzbek/Hazara supporting what had previously been the Northern Alliance (now mainly in power), and the Pashtuns supporting the Taliban, but now even the former are fed up with the U.S./NATO occupation...the fact that there is still an insurgency raging in the South and East is testament to the support they still have, since no insurgency can survive without local support.

As for Obama's 'revised strategy' this is an admission of failure..i.e. that the Taliban can only be contained and not 'defeated'..the fact will soon dawn on the on the U.S. and its allies/NATO that the sooner they leave Afghanistan to its people the better.......
(3) 2009-05-01 19:01:59
Asif:

The 'Taleban' are a bunch of uneducated idiots who should all by hanged.
(4) 2009-05-01 22:40:24
WTF!:

All hunky-dory... just as long as you are not a democrat, a woman, a Tajik, an Uzbek, a Shi'ah, a Sufi, a non-Muslim.

Shame on MPAC for giving this Taliban propaganda any space on its website.
(5) 2009-05-02 00:28:05
Shan:

Watched unreported world last night and was surprised to see the people of kabul not villagers saying they had more peace and security under the taliban government then the current government run by occupation forces.
so propaganda is nice but reality is sometimes hard to take in, the taliban provided security for people ,their lives were secure and their wealth protected.
The uzbeks-tajiks-shias had nothing to fear as the taliban did not kill innocent people,as for women they had the right not to be raped-molested or sold into prostitution, today in afghan this is what is happening to women, the choice is between starving to death, begging or selling yourself.
(6) 2009-05-02 14:56:31
Mitsubishi:

The 'Taleban' are a bunch of uneducated idiots who should all by hanged.
— Asif


asif, have you ever met Taliban do you even know what they stand for or how they practise Islam,

have been to Afghanistan?

i think your opinon comes from "as seen on tv"
(7) 2009-05-03 17:22:00
Commando:

Sounds like this Ahmed character should go to SWAT and smoke a spliff, or even better try to write an unbiased article, and well see what happens to him.
(8) 2009-05-03 21:42:47
Imran Karim:

Is someone going to be granted the pleasures of Paradise by Allah SWT because he prayed 5 times a day, kept a beard and fasted, but not because of his love for Allah but because of his fear of being beaten by the Taliban?

You do not spread the deen by beating and flogging your own people. You do not gain credit with Allah SWT by refraining from sin, not because you feared Him, but because you were scared of being pubished by the Taliban. Worship is about intention through the heart and mind, not fear of a regime.

The most populous Muslim country is Indonesia - yet no one is forced to pray or wear niqab there.

The hadith tell us that at the time of the Prophet PBUH, women were not locked up and kept out of sight. They were part of the society and treated well, to the extent that there are particular verses in the Quran commanding the Prophet PBUH to rule in favour of a woman who came to him with a complaint about her husband.

The first Muslim was a woman, a large majority of hadith were transmitted by the wives of the Prophet PBUH, and Ayesha was responsible for the education of huge numbers of people after the death of the Prophet. Would she have been able to do this if she was kept in the kitchen with niqab 24/7?

The treatment of women by the Taliban is a long-running pushtun cultural trait which is even evident amongst pushtun living in the West and is not Islamic, even under "strict Sharia" (whatever that is).

The naive promoters of Khilafa over-state the case for the Taliban, but fail to understand that Pushtun cultural rules are not the same as Islamic Shariah provisions for a functioning society.
(9) 2009-05-04 10:07:28
Taleban nil, reality many goals.:

So it was out-of-control warlords - not the Taleban (heavens, no!) who massacred thousands of men, women and children in Mazar-e-Sharif?

It was not the Taleban (but out-of-control unknown naughty people) who closed every hospital in Kabul to women?

It was not the Taleban who persecuted Shi'a, ethnic minorities, women, kite-fliers, men without big beards? Oh no - it was oddballs who called themselves (oddly enough) the Taleban.

It was not the Taleban who smashed to smithereens the priceless and irreplaceable artistic heritage of their own people? No it was a group of surrealists who dressed just like the Taleban.

And, of course, it was not the Taleban who made non-Muslims wear a yellow badge? No, of course not, it was a bunch of geriatric Nazis, dressed as Pashtun villagers, reliving the Third Reich.

Take your Taliban and get lost.
(10) 2009-05-04 16:17:56
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.