'JAIL Asghar Bukhari,' says Zionist Melanie Phillips In Spectator! Print E-mail
Wednesday, 24 December 2008

fear_in_the_eye.jpgA London-based think tank has revealed that the co-founder of a Muslim communal organisation whose spokespeople are used by mainstream media outlets has glorified terrorism and attacks on Israel. The Centre for Social Cohesion (CSC) reported that last week Asghar Bukhari, co-founder and spokesman for the Muslim Public Affairs Committee (MPACUK), said on the social networking site Facebook that any Muslim who died fighting Israel was a martyr.

Responding to comments by another contributor on a discussion entitled 'Has Europe come to terms with Islam?', Bukhari said, "Muslims who fight against the occupation of their lands are mujahadeen and are blessed by Allah. And any Muslim who fights against Israel and dies is a martyr and will be granted paradise."

The Muslim leader went on to justify jihadism, saying, "The concept of jihad is a beautiful thing, and logical to those with a sincere heart. It tells the human being to stand up and fight against those who bring evil and oppression on this earth, and by standing up - roll back that oppression until the people are free from it."

CSC called into question the media outlets' use of MPACUK and their portrayal of it as a mainstream Muslim organization. "The leadership of MPACUK has been shown before to have expressed opinions which border on glorification of terrorism," said Robin Simcox, a CSC researcher.

"Concern has previously been expressed to the BBC and other media about their continuing use of Bukhari and his organization. Despite this, they are regularly treated by the BBC and other mainstream media as representative of mainstream Muslim opinion," Simcox said.

"Bukhari's incitement and likely illegal public comments should be a matter of grave concern to broadcasters and others who have repeatedly given him and his organization a platform," Simcox added.

The think tank has reported the incident to the police.

Jerusalem Post, 22 December 2008

The article is in fact almost a straight reprint of a (pdf) CSC briefing.

Predictably Damian Thompson and Melanie Phillips have seized on this, with the latter calling for Asghar to be prosecuted.

Read MPACUK's reponse here. They rightly accuse the CSC of "wasting police time by reporting Asghar Bukhari for supposedly contravening the new law banning 'glorification of terrorism'. MPACUKwho actually care about stopping terrorism – expect our taxes to be spent trying to prevent anyone from blowing us up on tube trains (not dealing with politically-motivated malicious reports against media spokespeople from Muslim groups!)"

Once again we have a witch-hunt against mainstream Muslims, the origin of which can be traced back to the Islamophobic cesspool that is Harry's Place.

Source: From the superb and must-read blog, Islamophobia Watch




Reddit!Del.icio.us!Facebook!

Readers have left 38 comments.
MAQ:

The Centre for Social Crap should be prosecuted for the things it comes out with, along with that witch - Phillips.
(1) 2008-12-24 09:39:21
we all agree with Mr Bukhari:

Jail Mr Bukhari for expressing views, which we all hold??? That can’t be right; she’s out of her Israeli skull. I’m no fan of Mr Bukhari but the expressed view is absolutely correct. I believe every sane Men and Women in Israel is guilty of oppression and high crimes. Soon or later justice will be served in due proportion. I just hope that I can take part in holding them to account.
(2) 2008-12-24 10:10:01
Johnny P:

The Centre for Social Crap should be prosecuted for the things it comes out with, along with that witch - Phillips.
— MAQ


Truth is most people in the UK agree with what the mpac spokesperson has said.

If Asghar gets jailed for saying what he said, there is going to be a holy **** storm, the size of which neither the police nor the government could handle.
(3) 2008-12-24 11:01:35
ADW:

To fight evil and oppression, we need to oppose violent Islamism, as supported by Bukhari and his ilk- from their customary safe place of course.
(4) 2008-12-24 11:47:36
Syed:

I believe every sane Men and Women in Israel is guilty of oppression and high crimes.
— we all agree with Mr Bukhari
I wouldn't say EVERY Israeli man and woman are guilty. There are many Israeli Jews trying to bring an end to the occupation. Their efforts should be recognised and supported.
(5) 2008-12-24 11:48:57
Well Done Asghar:

For speaking the truth and exposing the hypocrisy of Philips.
(6) 2008-12-24 11:55:42
Simon:

I believe every sane Men and Women in Israel is guilty of oppression and high crimes.
— Syed
I wouldn't say EVERY Israeli man and woman are guilty. There are many Israeli Jews trying to bring an end to the occupation. Their efforts should be recognised and supported.
— we all agree with Mr Bukhari


A tiny minority! ... that does not excuse nor make up for the racist state as a whole.
(7) 2008-12-24 12:00:29
David:

It's about time someone exposed the sheer Islamophobia of so called "commentators" like Melaine Philips. Every Muslim knows what MPAC stands for; democratic participation, integration, an end to violence, a just settlement for the Palestinians so both sides can live in peace. How does the vile bigot Melanie Philips try to portray this? By calling for the arrest of one of the people who calls for such laudable things. Philips is a true bottom feeder, a vile Zionist harpy that tries to defend Israeli violence but then tries to silence anyone who protests on behalf of the Palestinians. She is the one who should be arrested for working against the interests of Britain on behalf of her beloved Israel. She turns my stomach.
(8) 2008-12-24 12:01:39
markuk:

Danish cartoons will cause 1000s of muslims in the uk to demonstrate violently.
Calling for heads to be cut off and chants of bomb the uk.
Some of you might say that this is an insult but there are many many jihadist arounds the world claming that your prophet was a violent person. I dont see muslims calling for their heads/
Why do you accept what asghar bukhari says but call for beheadings when none muslims claim that someone from 1400 years ago was a violent person.
Dont say islam is violent or we will call for your head
(9) 2008-12-24 12:02:55
Sista:

I think that they should try and file a complaint on Asghar Bukhari, it will do MPACUK some good. MPACUK's message encourages political perticipation and standing up against oppression and injustice. What part of that endorses terrorism? If anything this will blow up out of proportion in the media and therefore will give MPAC a platform to promote their stance of what their ethos and goal is. When Asghar's brief puts forward a challenge to zionists such as Melanie Phillips it will only make her and others (Doughlas Murray) hold their heads in shame for accusing a British citizen who stands up for human rights for defamation.
(10) 2008-12-24 13:12:15
Ishaaq:

it will only make her and others (Doughlas Murray) hold their heads in shame for accusing a British citizen who stands up for human rights for defamation.
— Sista

I think that is the problem, Murray and Mad Mel do not hold any Muslim to be a British citizen. As far as the are concerned we are nothing but illegal immigrants etc etc.
(11) 2008-12-24 13:35:07
Shamsur:

I think Melanie and her brother Douglas should be locked up for crimes against humanity.

Their very existence is a danger to us all. Somebody please lock up these dangerous animals
(12) 2008-12-24 13:37:39
D Cohen:

Not in my name. Zionism will never hijack judaism. We won't let it.

Melanie Phillips does not speak on behalf of the entire Jewish population.

With this latest stunt they are setting a very dangerous precedent for freedom of expression in this country.
(13) 2008-12-24 13:38:11
Tahira:

Melanie Phillips is a Zionist traitor who is prepared to undermine the freedom of British citizens to protect her beloved Israel from criticism.

If anyone want to arrest Asghar Bukhari for what he said then they're gonna have to arrest nearly 2 million other ordinary British Muslims with him - not to mention the many non-Muslim Brits who aren't taken in by Zionist scumbag journalists like Mad Mel.
(14) 2008-12-24 13:52:56
Another pro Israeli organization:

Is the CSC; UK’s version of the ADL (anti defamation league) of America?

These scoundrels have set up many organizations across the western world to silence anyone who speaks out against the Holocaust and genocide of the Palestinians. Their dream is to set up a dictatorial world government in Israel whereby they can enslave the world’s population and control all its recourses; quite a plan they have but will fail InshAllah. Check out ‘Why The Mid-East Bleeds’ by Ted Pike on Google video to get a glimpse into their murderous ideology. He has few other titles, check em all.
(15) 2008-12-24 14:10:15
shan:

Markuk the racist bigot lectures muslims again but refuses to condemn the racist and bigoted attacks in quenchwell and belper.
1000s demonstrated violently in the uk due to the danish cartoons, does one person count as a thousand in your rational, as i too watched and it was a around 50-70 people.
why go back 1400 years just look at christians-jews-hindus who have hundreds of thousand of terrorists occupying muslim nations and committing thousands of acts of terror here and now everyday.
(16) 2008-12-24 14:52:54
slickafoe:

Danish cartoons will cause 1000s of muslims in the uk to demonstrate violently.
Calling for heads to be cut off and chants of bomb the uk.
Some of you might say that this is an insult but there are many many jihadist arounds the world claming that your prophet was a violent person. I dont see muslims calling for their heads/
Why do you accept what asghar bukhari says but call for beheadings when none muslims claim that someone from 1400 years ago was a violent person.
Dont say islam is violent or we will call for your head
— markuk

TEhee!The Baboon is jumping up and down.MarkUk you are Pratt."Some of you might say that this is an insult but there are many many jihadist arounds the world claming that your prophet was a violent person"You really do talk excrement___WHERE IS YOUR PROOF?"Why do you accept what asghar bukhari says but call for beheadings when none muslims claim that someone from 1400 years ago was a violent person"have you tried to read your own illegible sentences?you really are an ignoramus.PLEASE, KEEP COMING ON THIS SITE TO MAKE A FOOL OF YOURSELF AND YOUR SCUMMY LIKE MINDED FOOLS."Dont say islam is violent or we will call for your head"ahh PER LEASEEEEEEE stop!im gonna wet myself laughing.Hahaaaaaaaaaa
(17) 2008-12-24 15:41:35
jail'em:

Israel is a symbol of oppression.It has invaded and waged war with all it's neighbours. It has imprisoned a whole nation. Occupied their lands. Has total disregard of International law and UN resolutions. Has committed genocide in many occassions in its short existence. Is practicing apartheid and suffocating the Palestinian people. Any person that fights against oppression and dies is a martyr. Any person that fights against oppression and gets injured is a martyr. Anyone with a pro-Israeli=zionist=fascist mindset should be jailed. Not those who fight and speak out against oppression. If those who fought against oppression were silenced in the 2nd world war then Nazi Germany would've had it's way. Israel is today's Nazi Germany.
(18) 2008-12-24 17:30:33
F Cockburn:

If it looks like a dog,
and barks like a dog.
It must be Melanie Phillips
Gross.
(19) 2008-12-24 17:32:49
F Ewell:

Melanie Phillips looks foul.
(20) 2008-12-24 17:38:01
Ian:

Why would anyone want to arrest an irrelevant non-entity like Asgar Bukhari?
(21) 2008-12-24 17:48:39
Ian:

Anyone with a pro-Israeli=zionist=fascist mindset should be jailed.
— jail'em


Why?
(22) 2008-12-24 18:08:36
irrelevant?:

Why would anyone want to arrest an irrelevant non-entity like Asgar Bukhari?
— Ian


So irrelevant that you had to read this article and make a comment. Eh?

Some people always snooker themselves because they don't think first. Don't mix sarcasm with stupidity.
(23) 2008-12-24 18:11:47
Simon:

My question to Melanie Philips is does she care about Britain or Israel?
(24) 2008-12-24 19:06:02
A A:

Maybe we should prosecute the Islamophobes for incitement to religious hatred.

That law was passed in 2006 I believe.
(25) 2008-12-24 22:33:01
Irrelevant:

I get the impression they read teh article and simply confirmed a pre-held impression that he is irrelevant.

Reading the article doesn't MAKE him relevant.

I happen to think that Bukhari is HIGHLY relevant and very useful. Very useful indeed!


Why would anyone want to arrest an irrelevant non-entity like Asgar Bukhari?
— irrelevant?


So irrelevant that you had to read this article and make a comment. Eh?

Some people always snooker themselves because they don't think first. Don't mix sarcasm with stupidity.
— Ian
(26) 2008-12-24 23:52:21
A. Paul:

We in Britain will not stand at all for Zionists like Melanie Phillips hijacking our papers for their own ends, ends which are for Zionism itself, and not for Britain and its values.

They attack our British traditions and our British way of life.
(27) 2008-12-25 09:23:05
Merry Xmas:

They attack our British traditions and our British way of life.
— A. Paul


In a way that Shariah wouldn't. If you have ever read Mel you will have noted one of here strong themes is the erosion of The British Way of Life. She is ALL for the maintenance of things like Christmas and often berates people like the ARchbishop of Canterbury for his destructive non-defence of Christianity, which is the foundation of Britishness as a nation.

You don't actually know what you are taking about!
(28) 2008-12-25 10:39:53
Father Christmas:

They attack our British traditions and our British way of life.
— Merry Xmas


In a way that Shariah wouldn't. If you have ever read Mel you will have noted one of here strong themes is the erosion of The British Way of Life. She is ALL for the maintenance of things like Christmas and often berates people like the ARchbishop of Canterbury for his destructive non-defence of Christianity, which is the foundation of Britishness as a nation.

You don't actually know what you are taking about!
— A. Paul


Thats interesting a Jewish Zionist woman telling the Archbishop of Canterbury how to protect Britain ....hmmmm

Nothing to do with hijacking nationlist feelings and using them to create Islamaphobia to benefit Israel then?
(29) 2008-12-25 12:09:30
A. Paul:

To ''Merry Xmas''

Zionist influence over our politicians, our media, including our main newspapers and our TV stations, is usurping our democracy and our way of life for one ned and one end only: themselves
(30) 2008-12-25 13:51:42
against the injustice:

what Br Asghar Bukhari meant by his comment was that everyone must protect their rights and not to allow any oppressor who ever it is to steal it from you, your honour, dignity, family, land and the main thing your freedom. in this case he ofcourse means palestine,everybody knows the zionists are the oppressors and occupiers of this land, they kill, steal and destroy everything has the palestenian and muslim ID on.as the recent attacks by the israeli civilians (the occupiers)on the palestinian properties where nobody raised the questions against the authority of committing such act and now everybody is awake when somebody like br Asghar defends the basic human rights.
(31) 2008-12-25 14:30:35
Abu_Maryam:

I think Asghar Bukhari should consult a libel lawyer, good oppurtunity to make a few bucks out of the Zionist like "mad Mel" and CSC.
(32) 2008-12-25 15:04:21
daudk khan:

salaam
Its ok for western nations to bomb the hell out of countries for oil and politics and there is no accountability - however when a muslim speaks about his right of self defence/jihad then there is a huge cry!
Is this western justice?
Double standards, what I say.
(33) 2008-12-25 15:21:49
Merry Xmas:

"Zionist influence over our politicians, our media, including our main newspapers and our TV stations, is usurping our democracy and our way of life for one ned and one end only: themselves "

In that case what would 'our democracy' be doing that they wouldn't be doing if there were no "Zionist pressure"?
(34) 2008-12-26 20:05:31
Bilal:

I agree with everything that Bukhari says. Allah bless him and Allah blast the zionist regime and their supporters. Their punishment is surely coming.

Philips and her kind are not British in any sense of that term. If the UK was bombing Israel (I pray for that day to come) she would not be siding with the UK.
(35) 2008-12-27 00:13:34
LAYLA:

I completely commend Asghar's bravery for speaking out speaking the truth.

Well done !!!
(36) 2008-12-29 13:22:41
FH:

Bukhari talks about fighting oppression, surely that should be on every decent human being's agenda! If Israel or any other country is oppressing humans, whether Muslim or not, then anyone fighting that cause is considered a martyr if he dies, but of course Allaah knows best. And we can all see who is oppressing who at this point. Why is it that when Muslims call on the world to fight oppression it is called 'terrorism' but the killing of innocents in Palestine, or around the world by non-Muslims is not called 'terrorsim?' What is America doing? What has Gordon Brown said? Aren't they encouraging terrorism against Palestinians, by supporting Israel and placing the onus on HAMAS? Who is the one with the upper hand in Israel...surely this is clear to the world???!!! So who is the oppressor and who is the oppressed???!! THINK!!
(37) 2009-01-02 17:44:37
Shazadkashmir:

Why doesnt anyone try to prosecute these journalists>?
(38) 2009-01-07 13:38:31
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.