| Failing Khyra |
|
|
| Thursday, 29 May 2008 | |
MPACUK Comment: Yet another child dies in Britain in scenes one would
expect to have read about from the developing world or the potato
famine. Khyra Ishaq, a seven year old, starved to death in Birmingham
in 2008. This story should shock us all. Of course her parents are the
prime suspects but the failing of young Khyra goes further. Where were
the social services for example? Tragically Khyra is not the first
child to perish through lack of action by professionals paid to protect
them. An old African saying goes “it takes an entire village to raise a
child” and this is true in any country. What were her neighbours doing?
Her extended family? How could her abuse go unnoticed? Her death shames
us all.
Family of Khyra Ishaq are “pulling together”
Source : Birmingham Mail
Readers have left 6 comments.
Don:
Quote
This is not the first time a child has died through failure of agencies who are paid to ensure protection for such children. Why aren't they in the dock also.
Their managment review should not be an affair that solely concerns them but should be a public affair that concerns the public. Heads should rightly roll but it is doubted they will. Rather the people invovled will be promoted. Manslaughter or child slaughter comes to mind. shame....
(1)
2008-05-30 09:42:11
Sultan (in Oxford):
Quote
Assalaam walaikum and Greetings
In cases like this, I always ask "how on earth can parents do this to their own flesh and blood". More sickening is that these were Muslim parents based upon the pictures I have seen on the TV (mother in hijab, father wearing a Muslim cap). It is all very easy to Blame Social Services for not doing their job, in retrospective, but Social Services only get involved when they perceive a real threat to the lives of the children. If the parents covered up the true condition of their child (and believe me, parents and families do cover up abuse towards their children for fear of their child being taken away) then you can't blame social services for failing to act. They only act if they have evidence of child abuse or someone has reported their concerns to them. Social Services are over-stretched and cannot act for every child who may/may not be abused. They have a fine line to tread, since they could be accused of over-reacting. The Blame lies flatly with the parents who would have known about the condition of their child, then the 'extended family' who would have seen her, then neighbours. Social services come last. Where was the 'extended family' when the child was suffering ?. It is all too easy for the 'extended family' to say "we are pulling together" or "we are strong" after the event. The point is, if you were that 'strong' and close, then you should have helped the child or at least reported your concerns to Social Services earlier. Wasalaams
(2)
2008-05-30 10:42:19
shan:
Quote
I think you should hold your horses on this one as it seems,we do not know the cause of death to date.
The official line is she may have or allegedly died from starvation,she had 4 or 5 other brtohers and sisters and none of them were starving so lets not follow the hype for the moment. Other than that those who abuse children by willfully starving them for weeks should have the same repaid back to them.
(3)
2008-05-30 10:53:02
Colin the Athiest:
Quote
This death shames us all? I don't think so. This death has nothing to do with me. The fault is the perpetrators no more no less. Attempting to shift the blame is perverse. Everyone has to standup for their actions.
The African saying quoted above may be true in Africa but not true in England for those who are mature and independent, indepent of thought and action. Most people in the UK are brought up to be so and can stand on their own two feet. The thought of my neighbours having a say in the upbringing of my children I find perverse.
(4)
2008-05-30 12:28:25
Elizabeth Thompson Khan:
Quote
Why do you express amazement at this horrific mistreatment of this poor child ?? After all it is the British culture and this is exactly what the British did during the brutal colonial era, where the British terrorists killed over 83-90 million people in Asia, Africa, Mideast & United Ireland. The favourite way of the British terrorists in terms of killing people in United Ireland, was to starve them to death and by doing so, they killed many million innocent Irish in United Ireland. So, now if the British are doing the same to their own, it is no surprise to us.
Elizabeth Thompson Khan Amsterdam Holland Cockroach_Britain100@yahoo.com.au
(5)
2008-05-30 22:15:53
Colin the Athiest:
Quote
Elizabeth Thompson Khan, if what you wrote was about a person it would be called libelous. Everything you stated was/is a lie or a distortion of the actual truth. I see you are in Holland. The same people who went to South Africa (Boer) and eventually brought in Apartheid. Did you know that? You clearly have an anti-British chip on your shoulder (I would like to know why) and therefore can bring nothing of note to the debate about this sad article.
(6)
2008-05-31 13:33:17
|






MPACUK Comment: Yet another child dies in Britain in scenes one would
expect to have read about from the developing world or the potato
famine. Khyra Ishaq, a seven year old, starved to death in Birmingham
in 2008. This story should shock us all. Of course her parents are the
prime suspects but the failing of young Khyra goes further. Where were
the social services for example? Tragically Khyra is not the first
child to perish through lack of action by professionals paid to protect
them. An old African saying goes “it takes an entire village to raise a
child” and this is true in any country. What were her neighbours doing?
Her extended family? How could her abuse go unnoticed? Her death shames
us all.











