Bhutto's Death Leads To Crisis of Democracy in Pakistan Print E-mail
Friday, 28 December 2007
benazir_bhutto_170px.jpgThe assassination of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto in Pakistan today is a shocking blow to the nation but also raises significant challenges to the future of democracy in Pakistan. Bhutto was killed by gunfire and a suicide bomb attack as she was leaving an election rally in Rawalpindi.

Bhutto’s return’s to Pakistan in October -after eight years of exile -was marred by similar scenes of chaos and a failed assassination attempt. At the time, Bhutto defiantly announced that she would not be deterred by such threats and would continue campaigning for the upcoming elections in January. Fellow campaigner and opposition party leader Nawaz Sharif has also narrowly escaped attempt on his life since his return to Pakistan. Since the return of both former Prime Ministers, there have been a number of similar incidents and violent demonstrations across the country, leading President Musharraf to impose marshal law. Just two weeks ago, the President lifted martial law, following intense pressure from home and abroad.

The killing is now likely to intensify Pakistan’s political crises and raises doubts about the possibility of January elections going ahead.

The restoration of democracy is the greatest challenge facing the country, but in the coming days and months, ensuring stability across the country will prove an immensely difficult task. Public grief and outrage has already begun to spill out on to the streets and as Pakistan has witnessed all too often, these demonstrations can potentially lead to widespread civil strife.

It is crucial that democracy does not become the scapegoat of this tragedy and that the government allows democratic elections to proceed as planned. 



Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Live!Facebook!Technorati!Spurl!Furl!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Readers have left 9 comments.
Osman Ghazi: Quote

What democracy in Pakistan?

Hasn't the country been ruled by a dictator for over a decade.

For good analysist on Pakistan go to www.icssa.org.
(1) 2007-12-28 07:59:40
Iqbal: Quote

good.
(2) 2007-12-28 10:19:43
shan: Quote

May Allah forgive her and give sabar to her family,she was taken out in a professional hit.
this is no the work of any extremist but of people with cold calculated plans,benazir was not bombing parts of pakistan it is mushraf and his cronies.
musharaf the dictator was named by bhutto as her killer if she was ever to be killed,she was hit by two bullets in the neck and head,it was a profesional hit pure and simple.
to see the media and western leaders support musharaf even now shows,that they do not care for democray but only want stooges in power,stooges like mushraf who will kill with impunity.
(3) 2007-12-28 11:30:06
M. A. Yusufzai: Quote

I found Benazir Bhutto's old friend Tariq Ali's comments on BBC World Service most objective. He said that the west made Musharraf white wash corruption changes on her and made her to return to Pakistan regardless of the dangers. He criticized Ms Bhutto for unnecessarily outraging the extremists by promising things that she could never do.

Anyway, one more "Martyr" has been added in Pakistani history. Let us pray that Pakistan itself does not become a history.

With due respect to Pakistanis, without making any comment, I cite two events that I will never be able to forget. In 2001 the court found the former Indian Prime Minister Narasimha Rao (now late) guilty of corruption during his tenure as Prime Minister and awarded imprisonment. Needless to say Mr Rao had a large following. But there was no protest from his followers and no one attacked the Supreme Court. Rao's supporters appealed against the decision and got him acquitted.

However, the same day when Mr Rao was sentenced, the supporters of the then ousted and imprisoned Prime Minister Nawas Shareef were protesting in front of Pakistan High Commission in London! One hardly needs to remind the corruption and other crimes of Mr Shareef. Will Pakistanis ever learn any lesson?

Again with due apology to Pakistanis no nation on earth goes as mad in supporting the corrupt rulers as the Pakistanis do.
(4) 2007-12-28 12:47:41
Colin: Quote

Please allow my comment on this terrible event, and possibly respond to shan.

Benazir was killed by Islamic extremists, I don't know, but probably Taleban/Al Queda.

Why? When Benazir was eventually elected in January, there would have been an alliance between her and the President to the detriment of the Islamic radicals in Pakistan. They would have been taken on and defeated, they knew it and have acted.

Regardless of the reasons, it is still a despicable and cowardly act.
(5) 2007-12-28 13:50:09
Taz: Quote

Benazir was a deeply flawed and corrupt individual who should have faced charges of corruption in Pakistan but having said that the people behind her killing are beyond contempt.

Pluralism is an essential element of democracy and I don't think she was a panacea against extremism but she talked a good talk and used her dynasty to control the PPP and give Pakistani's a choice of Liberalism and that is important in a democracy.

I hope a liberal party remains in Pakistan whether that is the PPP or some new party is unimportant as long as people are given a real choice, free from fear and that all sides respect the law.

It is interesting that the PPP leadership are not calling for their supporters to stop burning down hospitals, train stations and private property. They seem to be vengeful even blaming Musharraf who warned Benazir of attempts on her life. warnings she ignored instead flouting all the security protocols to revel in the limelight. She sat in an armoured van and only when she stood up out of the sun roof was that assassin able to carry out his wicked un-Islamic crime.

She was no saint. Far from it but may Allah show her mercy.
(6) 2007-12-28 15:08:59
azaad: Quote

Pakistan should now take the opportunity to arrest all beardy Mullahs, and any who fail to recite the whole Quraan by heart, as well as to transalte any given verse, should be pronounced as frauds.

The extremists should, once and for all, be eradicated from Pakistan's public life. Any political party that doesn't subscribe to a pluralist democracy should be deemed illegal.

Domestic violence against women should be made punishable by a life-sentence.

At least a third of all election candidates should be women.

It is also time for Punjabis to share power: otherwise the remaining provinces should break away and become independent countries (as happened with East Pakistan/Bangladesh). It is the failure of Punjabis to let go of their greed for monopoly on power that is the biggest obstacle to progress towards Pakistan's full potential. It is also the same Punjabi addiction to power, and disdain of democracy, that lost Pakistan one half of the country in 1971.
(7) 2007-12-29 00:42:29
karlos: Quote

Watch this video with Sir David Frost, Benazir Bhutto reveals that Omar Sheik, the former MI6 agent now in a Pakistani prison killed Osama bin Ladin. She makes the revelation in an off-hand remark at about 6m12s into the interview.
Is this why she was killed? Because she exposed the CIA fairytale of Osama Bin Ladin's videos and attributed quotes when in reality he was kiled in 2002
http://www.youtube.com/v/oIO8B6fpFSQ&rel=1
(8) 2007-12-29 05:04:32
Islamic Torch: Quote

don't worry she used to watch the wizrd of oz - i wonder was she dorothy or the witch?
(9) 2007-12-29 22:18:54
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.