| Peer Pressure |
|
|
| Monday, 03 December 2007 | |
MPACUK warmly welcomes the pardoning of school teacher Gillian Gibbons after her sentencing under Sudanese blasphemy laws. Her presidential pardon was secured by the efforts of Labour peer Lord Nazir Ahmed and Conservative peer Baroness Sayeeda Warsi. Their negotiations with the Sudanese government were entirely separate from the official and ultimately unsuccessful British government negotiations.Both the Labour Party and the Conservatives would be wise to respect their respective Muslim peers a little more in the future. There was a lot of hostility within Conservative ranks about the enoblement of Baroness Warsi, an articulate young Muslim female from the North of England. Lord Ahmed has also had quite a trying relationship with the Labour leadership in the past. It seems their peerages have already reaped dividends, and they should be warmly congratulated upon their return. This whole sorry saga was blown out of all proportion by the Sudanese government who seemed willing to allow a miscarriage of justice to take place in front of the world against a teacher who came to Sudan to educate their children. Children often anthromorphosise their toys and in the case of this teddy bear, rather than perceive the naming of the toy as some calculated act of blasphemy, the government should have realised this was a child's mark of affection. Incredibly, this seemingly innocent act became a full-blown international diplomatic incident. The only winners from this incident are the toy manufacturers and Britain's growing number of Islamophobes. It is also worth noting that Ms Gibbons’ MP is Louise Ellman. The Labour MP for Liverpool Riverside and rather shrill member of the controversial lobby group Labour Friends of Israel. No doubt Ms Ellman would have been obliged to write to the Sudanese government, but because of her historic hostility towards Muslim governments and Muslim organisations, her letter would have had zero impact. It is also worth noting that Boris Johnson, the Conservative prospective mayoral candidate for London, hankered after old-fashioned gunboat diplomacy. It would be difficult to imagine a more inappropriate person to run the great city of London. MPACUK, other British Muslims organisations and individual British Muslims all called for the immediate release of Ms Gibbons. MPACUK lobbied the Sudanese through the media, wrote to the Sudanese Ambassador and protested outside the Sudanese embassy. One of the positive aspects of this sorry saga was the proof, if any were needed, that there isn't a dichotomy between Britain's Muslims and non-Muslims. We can all be on the same side and given the chance, Britain’s Muslims can provide a positive contribution to our nation. No prizes for guessing what the best selling toy for Christmas is going to be! Readers have left 19 comments.
Muhammad Elamin:
Quote
Just a quick correction:
She was charged under article 125 of the Sudanese penal law; there is no seperate law for blasphemy in the Sudan
(1)
2007-12-03 12:14:07
Quaqa:
Quote
Welldone to the Muslim peers for securing the release. The moderate face of Islam is the Winner.
(2)
2007-12-03 13:18:40
MelanieP:
Quote
"It is also worth noting that Ms Gibbons’ MP is Louise Ellman. The Labour MP for Liverpool Riverside and rather shrill member of the controversial lobby group Labour Friends of Israel. No doubt Ms Ellman would have been obliged to write to the Sudanese government, but because of her historic hostility towards Muslim governments and Muslim organisations, her letter would have had zero impact"
Completely uneccessary comment. It just shows the underlying nastiness. I welcome "Moderate Islam" being the winner. Obviously, that means we acknowledge an intolerant fundamentalist Islam also exists otherwise you cannot use the modifier "Moderate". Do moderate Muslims follow a different Koran to intolerant fundamentalist Muslims?
(3)
2007-12-03 14:24:27
abuzainab:
Quote
Quaqa - there no such thing as moderate Islam. Islam is Islam that is it - one Quran, One Prophet
(4)
2007-12-03 17:02:52
Stephen Power:
Quote
Well done to the group of MPAK demonstrators outside the Sudan embassy on Saturday. Though it was a small group - pictures appeared at least in The Sunday Times and in the Metro, read by millions each morning.
(5)
2007-12-03 17:10:59
Tahira:
Quote
This really demonstrates the unique benefit Muslims bring to Britain when we are not marginalised.
(6)
2007-12-03 17:51:24
Islamic Torch:
Quote
Well lets move on to some real news - she has been release .. whoppee (Yawn).
How sad that two brown noses go to Sudan - if I had been the President of Sudan - i would have questioned why is it 2 Muslims are sent? Why didn't the PM go himself or send the Foreign Secretary - because they didn't want to be seen grovelling to a Muslim leader.....
(7)
2007-12-03 19:19:50
Colin:
Quote
Good news that two moderate Muslims have helped save the schoolteacher from the clutches of immoderate Muslims. But, I hope all infidels will take a lesson from this and stay well clear of such clutches from now on. Don't hand hostages to fortune!
(8)
2007-12-03 22:08:27
Chuk de!:
Quote
Well lets move on to some real news - she has been release .. whoppee (Yawn). — Islamic TorchHow sad that two brown noses go to Sudan - if I had been the President of Sudan - i would have questioned why is it 2 Muslims are sent? Why didn't the PM go himself or send the Foreign Secretary - because they didn't want to be seen grovelling to a Muslim leader..... well done Ahmed and Warsi, keep it up :)
(9)
2007-12-03 23:14:35
MelanieP:
Quote
Well lets move on to some real news - she has been release .. whoppee (Yawn). — Islamic TorchHow sad that two brown noses go to Sudan - if I had been the President of Sudan - i would have questioned why is it 2 Muslims are sent? Why didn't the PM go himself or send the Foreign Secretary - because they didn't want to be seen grovelling to a Muslim leader..... The visit by Ahmed and Warsi was a completely private affair and they paid their own expenses. It was a private initiative and well-done for realising the negative impact this was having for the Muslim community in Britain and for the Worl impression of Islam. In the end the Muslim leader realised they had made a big mistake and stained Islam with their decsion and so they capitulated to commonsense. Why they never had it up-front is due to their strict adherence to Islamic law as they interpreted it.
(10)
2007-12-04 07:37:56
you muppet:
Quote
Louise ELman,
nice article mpac, things like her can slip under the rador, good to see you exposed the Islamophobic hag to the muslim public.
(11)
2007-12-04 09:22:29
azaad:
Quote
I am so delighted by the way MPAC is starting to make a real difference.
The campaign to get Gillian freed is the latest in a line of moves that deserve recognition. I think that MPAC should now press for the following: get the Government to utilise British Muslim leaders(?) &/or senior politicians more widely involved in foreign policy initiatives in the middle east: isn't that an obvious next step? The success of Baroness Warsi and Lord Ahmed just shows what an, as yet, untapped foreign policy resource Britain's muslim population is.
(12)
2007-12-04 10:05:02
TeddyBear:
Quote
I am so delighted by the way MPAC is starting to make a real difference. — azaadThe campaign to get Gillian freed is the latest in a line of moves that deserve recognition. I think that MPAC should now press for the following: get the Government to utilise British Muslim leaders(?) &/or senior politicians more widely involved in foreign policy initiatives in the middle east: isn't that an obvious next step? The success of Baroness Warsi and Lord Ahmed just shows what an, as yet, untapped foreign policy resource Britain's muslim population is. Keep them, and people like them, away from ANY policy-making whatsoever. Policies must reflect the majority democracy. They aren't elected (in fact they are rejected). Anyway, we have several Muslim MP's and that reflects our democratic society.
(13)
2007-12-04 14:29:50
wendy mann:
Quote
i think it is interesting that the government and newsmedia hacks sought to get some propaganda out of 'muslims doing the right thing in their eyes.' as if to say 'we' are taming the savages to the ways of the civilised world.
the fact remains she inadvertantly broke sudanese law and had a trial and convicted. there is no excuse for being ignorant of the law in law. the fact that gordon brown claimed the sudanese were 'completely wrong' is a sign of the ignorance arrogance and bigotry of some people in the uk. not only should muslims adhere to british values at home now the sudanese now should adhere to british values in sudan . the only person to come out of this with dignity has been mrs gibbons who has not thus far kowtowed to the baying for blood news reporting editors of our so called civilised news media.
(14)
2007-12-04 15:04:45
TeddyBear:
Quote
i think it is interesting that the government and newsmedia hacks sought to get some propaganda out of 'muslims doing the right thing in their eyes.' as if to say 'we' are taming the savages to the ways of the civilised world. — wendy mannthe fact remains she inadvertantly broke sudanese law and had a trial and convicted. there is no excuse for being ignorant of the law in law. the fact that gordon brown claimed the sudanese were 'completely wrong' is a sign of the ignorance arrogance and bigotry of some people in the uk. not only should muslims adhere to british values at home now the sudanese now should adhere to british values in sudan . the only person to come out of this with dignity has been mrs gibbons who has not thus far kowtowed to the baying for blood news reporting editors of our so called civilised news media. Wendy, you shouldn't use the word 'ignorance'. If Islam (Sudanese Version) is supposed to be a follower of a man who is 'compassionate and merciful" then how come they didn't exercise 'compassion and mercy' towards a teacher. A teacher who has dedicated her life to children. Where is YOUR "compassion and mercy"? Obviously drained from you.
(15)
2007-12-04 17:36:46
shan:
Quote
so next time a person brakes the law ,then he should be allowed to keep breaking the law because the faith of the people is dedicated to compassion and mercy.
i wonder why 100,000 people are in jail in britain after all we are followers of the man who said if someone slaps you on one cheek turn the other one to him as well. the question is why is your compassion only awakened in this matter what about the tens of thousands locked up for allegedly breaking the law. there are laws i do not like but i have to follow them as they are laws of the land,
(16)
2007-12-04 18:04:30
TeddyBear:
Quote
so next time a person brakes the law ,then he should be allowed to keep breaking the law because the faith of the people is dedicated to compassion and mercy. — shani wonder why 100,000 people are in jail in britain after all we are followers of the man who said if someone slaps you on one cheek turn the other one to him as well. the question is why is your compassion only awakened in this matter what about the tens of thousands locked up for allegedly breaking the law. there are laws i do not like but i have to follow them as they are laws of the land, shan, I think you're not quite getting this concept of compassion. Maybe a refresher course an a Madrassa might help.
(17)
2007-12-04 20:47:02
Bananas:
Quote
Good news. But in my opinion what this 'actually' proves at another level, is that some Muslims in certain parts of the world will only deal with other Muslims. Not Kafirs. Their loyaltys only lie with other Muslims. Nobody seemed to have picked up on that one. After all, haven't many Muslims here in Britain been heard sayind - "Islam first, British second"? Do you hear Christians or Jes saying - "Jewish or Christian first, British second"? I would also point out that everybody is patting themselves on the back but doesn't know actually what went on in that room. People are assuming it was 'islamic ways' which solved this crisis. For all we know, Sudan could have been threatened that Aid would stop. After all, these two peers were agents of the UK government. Or do Muslims see these peers as Muslims first and foremost, going as Muslims and not representatives of Britain?
(18)
2007-12-04 21:31:05
wendy mann:
Quote
If Islam (Sudanese Version) is supposed to be a follower of a man who is 'compassionate and merciful" then how come they didn't exercise 'compassion and mercy' towards a teacher. A teacher who has dedicated her life to children. Where is YOUR "compassion and mercy"? Obviously drained from you. you might as well ask where is the compassion of the jewish people when it comes to the palestinians. in islam there is the choice of compassion and there is punishment, retribution. it is upto the individual. the better choice is compassion but in islam it is not the only choice.
(19)
2007-12-05 18:58:19
|






MPACUK warmly welcomes the pardoning of school teacher Gillian Gibbons after her sentencing under Sudanese blasphemy laws. Her presidential pardon was secured by the efforts of Labour peer Lord Nazir Ahmed and Conservative peer Baroness Sayeeda Warsi. Their negotiations with the Sudanese government were entirely separate from the official and ultimately unsuccessful British government negotiations.










