Adverts

Please click on our sponsors to show your support

Journalism Diversity Fund
Losing The Propaganda War Print E-mail
Monday, 16 April 2007

276813_newspaper_job_section.jpgThe West's effort to demonise Iran as the 'evil empire' has taken a severe beating after the release of all 15 British sailors

Western propaganda efforts to demonise Iran as the evil empire have taken a severe beating after the public relations fiasco over the recent capture and release by Tehran of British sailors charged with illegally straying into Iranian waters. 

Displaying impressive propaganda skills, Iranian authorities managed to be a step ahead of their British counterparts through the entire drama from the capture of the 15 member Royal Navy crew, their weeklong captivity and their dramatic unconditional release. The British Government has further dented its credibility by getting embroiled in an ugly controversy over brokering lucrative deals for some of the released sailors to tell their stories to the London tabloid press.
 
Much of the egg on British Prime Minister Tony Blair's face today is because of his Government's too-clever-by-half decision to use the detention of the British sailors from Iranian waters as a propaganda ploy to corner the Islamic regime in Iran. But much to London's surprise, instead of getting cornered and defensive, Tehran turned the tables by playing the propaganda game with as much enthusiasm and considerably more skill. 
 
Downing Street was clearly stunned when Iranian authorities released pictures and videos of the incarcerated sailors looking relaxed in captivity and to make matters worse admitting that they were guilty of breaking maritime rules.

British discomfiture at the losing propaganda battle turned to alarm after two of the captured sailors, including the lone female member of the crew, Faye Turney, went to the extent of condemning the presence of Western forces in Iraq. Although there were no palpable signs of physical coercion from the Iranian authorities, London denounced the move as deliberate public humiliation of the captive sailors violating their fundamental human rights. Not surprisingly, these claims sounded a bit hollow considering the recent examples of real gruesome humiliation and torture of Muslim prisoners in Western detention centres like Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo.
 
Tehran scored another propaganda point when it decided to release all the captured sailors without any conditions. Once again it was the Iranians who scored a public relations coup. Television images of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad magnanimously ordering the release and the Royal Navy crew lining up to shake his hands and offer apologies for breaking the law emphasised how badly had the British propaganda bid to isolate Iran had boomeranged.
 
After getting the sailors safely back home, British authorities yet again sought to put a spin on the release by getting the released Navy crew to publicly deny all that they had said during captivity and put out a new version of what now was described as a 'nightmarish experience'. A couple of them also gave colourful interviews to the British tabloid press about their ordeal in Iran. 
 
Patriotic bias may well have lent credibility to these new versions of what happened to the British sailors in Iranian captivity at least in their homeland had their accounts not become mired in a fresh controversy over the huge sums of money they were paid to sell their stories to the media. It now turns out that the British Government was directly involved in facilitating these lucrative deals, which has sparked off a nationwide furore and caused further global embarrassment to the UK and allies like the US. 

Since only a few of the captured crew were chosen as the lucky ones to make their fortune by telling stories, the other sailors who had been held captive have openly rubbished their colleagues and lambasted the Government.

Mr Blair who is about to depart from his job has conveniently disowned all responsibility for the fiasco leaving the hapless Defence Secretary Des Browne to face the music. With big bucks emerging as a prime motive for the stories told by the sailors on their days in Iranian captivity, the little credibility left with Western propagandists about the 'nasty Iranians' have been shredded to bits. 

Meanwhile, Tehran is planning to make a film on the entire drama and release it to the international media.

Leaders and commentators in the West are fond of describing their war with Islamic zealots as a battle between the forces of civilised democracy and barbaric fundamentalism. The problem is that this claim has been repeatedly exposed as outright hypocrisy. It is the shrinking number of people across the world who genuinely believe that Western democracies are good guys that should be the real worry for the latter.

Source: DailyPioneer.com




Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Live!Facebook!Technorati!Spurl!Furl!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Readers have left 9 comments.
Kathy: Quote

Well done MPAC for posting this article. I will wait with joy to see the film by the Iranians once it is released. Ahmadinajad has truly won this 'propaganda war'. Our Government has been left with many 'eggs on faces' and the whole debacle is something that Blair should be ashamed of. I find it hard to believe that he was not aware of the 'story selling' issue. He probably hoped that it would be good propaganda against Iran but instead it backfired and has become a great embarrassment to our Forces and Government. I was actually amazed at how many people were angered by the 'story selling'. I noticed on a SKY News poll it was over 87% against the sailors being paid for their stories. Yes, if they had wanted to come out and tell the media about their time in Iran perhaps that was OK. They at least came home alive and well that week, unlike 4 of their Army colleagues.

No doubt Des Browne will be 'spun' today in Parliament but it is Blair who should be made to pay the price of his 'spin'. Yes, Mr Blair, that could be your legacy, 'The Spinning Prime Minister'. Al least it is somewhat better than some of the other suggestions I've made.
(1) 2007-04-16 09:21:13
Africana: Quote

The western propagandist especially the atrocious barbaric zombie press need to be reminded that it was their government that assasinated the democratically elected Iranian leader because he cared more about his people and couldn't give a damn about the luxury spoilt neo cancerous virus.

Iranians know this too well and the Iranians have always been known to be the master of diplomacy, the west tried to taint this with their inmecil translation of the Iranian leader's speech - which also backfired.

the higher justice!!
(2) 2007-04-16 12:33:40
J K: Quote

When one of the captured sailors was asked how he was mistreated by his Iranian captors, his reply was:

"They took away my ipod & called me Mr Bean"

Wow....such inhuman treatment.
(3) 2007-04-16 14:19:45
a2b: Quote

"They took away my ipod & called me Mr Bean"

I creased up laughing when I heard that.

If only Bush & Balir treated the innocent people they locked up in Guantanamo like that.
(4) 2007-04-16 16:14:51
Kathy: Quote

What I would like to know is what that young man was doing carrying or using an i pod whilst on duty, supposedly serving his country. Calling him Mr Bean was a far better name than I could call him after admitting that he cried himself to sleep. These are the young people who are being sent out to fight and die for our country. He has shown his true colours in taking money for his confession.
(5) 2007-04-16 20:53:42
Imran: Quote

lol!! 'They called me Mr Bean' - That is hilarious!!I can jus imagine the Iranian Guards saying it too.lolObviously it doesn't reflect the entire British Army, but these soldiers are a huge embarassment to the entire nation.
(6) 2007-04-17 02:46:30
Judge Dredd: Quote

Praise be to God.

It is great that the propoganda war is failing the Zionists.

I have to say, and not being a Shiite, Iran does indeed give some air of respect and dignity to Muslims.

I wish other Muslim nations could learn that Islam can go hand in hand with logic, self esteem and fairness.

I hope that HMV will sell this CD from Iran - I look forward to it entering the Charts.
(7) 2007-04-17 09:27:03
wendymann: Quote

Not to worry, the Americans are claiming today that Iran is supplying weapons in Afghanistan (allegedly intercepted) and yet they cant provide any proof that it is govt. backed . Hmmm .

With the UK and the USA trying to make the same claims in Iraq, it seems we are on another anti Iran campaign after this sailors debacle.

Blair is a very vain man, it will be only this reason we will find ourselves dropping bombs on innocent Iranians.
(8) 2007-04-17 22:09:04
Kathy: Quote

When I hear the Americans talking about Iran supplying weapons to Iraqi insurgents and Taliban , I wonder how they can criticise when they have been the biggest providers of weapons to some of the worst dictators on this earth, including Saddam, for decades.

They are just looking for that excuse to bomb Iran and if Blair backs them then he needs to leave NOW.
(9) 2007-04-18 09:35:53
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.