Britain should integrate into Muslim values Print E-mail
Thursday, 04 January 2007

430349_union_jackIn 2006 the gloves came off in the fight to define what it means to be British. Whereas the dominant response to the London bombings was confusion over how anyone raised in this country could commit such atrocities, the veil debate detonated by Jack Straw and the teaching assistant Aisha Azmi was notable for its muscularity. Sentiments that might once have been considered too insensitive were openly expressed. "The right to be in a multicultural society," argued the prime minister in a speech last month, "was always implicitly balanced by a duty to integrate, to be part of Britain." Behind these remarks was an assumption that integration is a one-way street. However, there are many things that the rest of the country could learn from Muslims.

In the present climate, integration is the only show in town and multiculturalism has joined political correctness as a favoured target of those who feel that their Britain is disappearing before their eyes. Hence the calls, growing ever louder, for Muslims to integrate: no more forced marriages; no more honour killings; accept the rule of law.

Think of the words "Muslim community" and what do you see? A succession of veiled women walking silently behind their husbands? Bearded men gesticulating outside mosques? But there is another version of the Muslim community.

It is easy to dismiss Muslim parents as old-fashioned and traditional, but when the rest of the country is busy wondering how to respond to a culture of rampant disrespect, it is worth considering whether they could learn from Muslim values. Muslim children are more likely to be brought up in two-parent families rather than the single-parent households that are increasingly common in Britain.

Muslim parents also tend to be less interested in child-centred parenting and more into parent-centred parenting. For example, when I was growing up there was no possibility of answering back to my parents, and this was accompanied by an all-pervasive fear of letting them down. This was a model of parenting that put great faith in deference and, while at the time it felt regressive, it was also what kept my generation in check.

My father often used the threat of "what might the community say?" as a weapon to control my rebellious teenage desires. I resented the power that this community had over me, but it is only now that I can appreciate its value. The knowledge of the hardship our parents had endured, alongside their old-fashioned attitudes towards parenting, meant most second-generation Muslims simply did not have the opportunity or desire to cause trouble. Instead we were conditioned not to get mad at whites but to get even, by making something of our lives.

Many members of my parents' generation may have been uneducated, employed in manual labour and unable even to speak English, but they raised their children to value values. They instilled in them a strong moral code, in which children's greatest fear was of bringing shame on their family. Their children learned that responsibility to their parents does not end at the age of 18. That is why so many British Muslims live in extended families today; why my brother lives next door to my mother so that his children can see their grandmother every day; and why our mother does not feel abandoned and useless in her old age. If the greatest weakness of the Muslim community has been its insularity, then that has also been the source of its greatest strengths.

As the clamour for British Muslims to integrate grows louder, it is worth remembering that, amid all the negatives arising from living inside a tightly knit community, there are also positives worth retaining - the greater the integration, the weaker the sense of community. It is the third generation - those in their teens and 20s who have been raised by parents often more liberal than my parents' generation - who are the young men and women now tarnishing the reputation of British Muslims.

Whether the danger is religious extremism, drugs or crime, those involved are largely third-generation Muslims who are so integrated into white society that they are emulating its worst characteristics. Integration did not save them, it created them.

www.sarfrazmanzoor.co.uk

Source: guardian.co.uk




Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Live!Facebook!Technorati!Spurl!Furl!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Readers have left 10 comments.
Tabish: Quote

I'm sick of these Integrating debates,and people tell the muslim community to integrate, We're as much integrated as everyone else into this society..
(1) 2007-01-05 07:28:35
Masud: Quote

Integration does not mean giving up your religion,culture,ideals or pinciples it means accepting that you have a postive role to play in the society that you are a "MEMBER" of. We have as the writer has noted some fantastic values in the muslim community and integration will show UK society our values, and in turn this bring harmony and understanding which is what we all want. It seem now that the word integration is being used as a beating stick by all partys do further thier own extreme ideologys we need to look past that and make efforts to be productive muslims and productive members of UK Society. One piece within that arguement that really hits out is the community bit, The so called muslim community is possibly the single biggest reason why muslims are in the position that they are in, And the sooner we disband the shackles of this institution the better
(2) 2007-01-05 11:51:29
Showkat: Quote

Integration YES
But not at the cost of losing our Islamic identity. Look at the example of the Jews in Germany in the 1930's who integrated and assimilated into German society and thought they were Germans.

Then from the beer halls and taking advantage of economic recession Hitler emerged and made the Jews his scapegoats. So weakened were the Jews due to assimilation that thye were unable to resist and many died in the gas chambers saying " This cant be happening to us".
(3) 2007-01-05 12:03:40
Al: Quote

And if the United Kingdom Independence Party get their way we will have to sign up their 'Muslim Charter' like good little boys and girls so we can intergrate into Western society and be told how behave and what parts of the Quaran we can read.
(4) 2007-01-05 12:13:56
Justice: Quote

It is regrettable that the writer failed to distinguish between tradition and religion. The phrase "what might the community say?" is more to do with tradition rather than religion. A Muslim fears Allah not the community.

I don't like to generalise, but I usually find that the older generation was more interested in their children becoming doctors and engineers than they were interested in whether they've done their prayers on time or not.

Even when elders insisted that their children prayed, they focused on the physical actions of the prayer rather than the spiritual side.

The youngsters today fail to see why should they stick to the traditions of a country that they never lived in, nor will they ever live in. I think the parents should instil more Islamic values rather than traditions. Unfortunately, you can only give what you have. If the parent doesn’t have those values, how can they pass on what they don't have?!

The new generation seems split into 2 groups. Those who rejected the old traditions and tried accepting the “western traditions” but only managed to get the worst part of that and those who went back to Islamic values but in the lack of proper guidance from the parents, some have taken the extreme root. The group that managed to strike the right balance seems in the minority. May Allah help those to guide the rest.
(5) 2007-01-05 12:15:40
Zak: Quote

'Integration' is a misnomer, just see what happens to 'integration' when a asian/black family moves into a white area.

Also ever heard of the 'white flight'?
(6) 2007-01-05 14:02:34
Rachael Greenwood: Quote

The idea of Britain generating a successful multicultural/multifaith society seems idealistic when problems such as integration and tolerance are overlooked. The questions which need to be adressed are those concerning what we all share (our commonality)while respecting our differences. It seems that it is hard for us to strike a balance for respect and tolerance for eachothers space.
(7) 2007-01-05 16:15:28
Kathy: Quote

I do believe that our society today could learn a lot from the Muslim family values. I was brought up in the 1950's and 60's and our society and family life at that time was much the same as the Muslims live today. My grandparents and aunties lived very close to us, we were disciplined and if a policeman told you off (usually with a clip around the ear) in those days, you would not dare tell your parents, for fear of more punishment. I can also relate to the statement, "what the community might say", in fact my parents, now in their 80's, still have that attitude.

Our society has gone out of control, with teenage pregnancies, drugs and street violence. In many parts of towns and cities, there is no respect for the law and the children in our schools no longer respect their teachers and certainly do not fear them as we used to. I certainly do not think that Muslims should be told to 'integrate' into this society, rather we should learn from them and return to the family values we used to have a couple of generations back.
(8) 2007-01-05 17:16:06
thoughtful: Quote

Britain has already integrated into and committed itself to muslim values. It's just that Muslims and muslim countries haven't yet caught on and put the same values into practice and are too busy being made to fight 'battles' which are created to keep them busy. Muslims have lost their way and have been purposely blinded to their true inheritance.

Where can you find more tolerance than in Islam?. Where is the freedom to pracise ones religion come from? Where is oppression and racism not acceptable? When was democracy first practiced except in the election of Hazrat Abu Bakr (may allah be pleased with him)?
(9) 2007-01-05 18:55:35
Shazy: Quote

The fundamental problem as I see is that as yet the Islamic community has yet to define what exactly are Islamic values. Because we are not a homogenous group there are simply no single set of values. Rather there are a range of values across the plethora of communities, and at some points we agree.
One group of Muslims can believe that all peoples should live together in peace and with legal equality. Others espoused a view that we should all live in peace as long as non-Muslims accept Muslim hegemony.
There are concepts in Islam which are alien to other communities, such as Dar-El-Harb, which we need to understand from the perspective of the non-Muslim and acknowledge the validity of their reaction to it. Clearly as this concept is part of the Islamic value system it must be a barrier to the acceptance of collective Muslim values by non-Muslims. We may argue that these concpets have fallen into redundancy and are no longer applicable, but their status in Islam has no equivalence in other religions. The equivalent in Christianity have been edicts by various leading figures but not espoused by the founders of that faith. Thus non-Muslims can easily eshew them and regard them as abberations which we cannot.
The real barrier to a a general acceptance of values to further integration remains the heightened introspective sensitivity that the Muslim communities evince and the degree of political and social immaturity. Our leaders tend to be leaders of this introspection and their attitude colours all engagement with the outside world.
(10) 2007-01-08 08:38:07
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.