Choose Your Region

UK-Region IRELAND-region
MPACUK LEEDS

Adverts/Promotions

Powered by: MuslimPages
 
Kent Muslim Welfare Association Halal Hamper CHL Properties When Slaves Become the Masters Journalism Diversity Fund Stop War On Iran

Disclaimer: MPACUK does not select these automated ads.


Subscribe to our newsletter:


Muslim TV crew stopped under terror law Print E-mail
Sunday, 01 June 2008

modeling_police_hijab.jpgA Muslim TV producer has accused the police of constantly targeting her crew and stopping them from filming in the streets of London. The crew from an international Muslim network, which included three hijab wearing members, were filming in Notting Hill, west London, in March when they said they were stopped and quizzed.

Producer Anousheh Demartino, who was stopped on three previous occasions, told The Muslim News, “They asked us for our ID and why we were filming. After we told them we were allowed to continue. 20 minutes later we were stopped again. This time we were asked for our residential address; they only asked me, the two other hijab wearing women and not [our] young cameraman.

“I protested at first and asked why they needed my home address when it was a professional not a personal matter, but he insisted and, not wanting to prolong the incident, I gave him the details.” Anousheh says she was given no legal reasons as to why they were stopped filming; however, she did say the officer made a reference to terrorist activity: “The officer, he said we need permission to film and made an example of the camera being used for terrorist activity. So he was saying he stopped us because of the size of the camera, because we were using a tripod…ultimately they are judging who is and is not a terrorist by the size of the camera.”

Speaking of her “frustrating” experience as a Muslim journalist she said, “I was stopped before with another crew and given report slips once on High Street Kensington in February and once on Victoria Road. We have to carry those slips with us all the time. I don’t know why we constantly get stopped, is it because we are not a large mainstream media [outlet], or is it because I wear the hijab?”

In a statement to The Muslim News a spokesperson for the Metropolitan police said, “There are some sensitive locations in London where it would not be unusual for those filming or taking photographs to be stopped and spoken to by police. If you have a UK Press Card, which has a number of security measures and is recognised by the Association of Chief Police Officers, you should not experience problems. It is also not unusual for reporters to be asked for their home address.”
The incident came a month before a Muslim BBC journalist was held to the ground by police officers after his radio equipment was mistaken for an explosive device.

The two episodes also came shortly before Chairman of the Metropolitan Police Federation, Peter Smyth, said officers are not sufficiently trained in how to correctly apply anti-terror legislation when dealing with photographers.

In an interview with 4’s PM programme on April 26, he addressed the increasing concerns that photographers are being unfairly stopped and questioned by police when taking photos in public places. Asked what innocent photographers should say to the officer if they are stopped, Smyth said, “If the officer has serious concerns that the photographs…are of some sort of terrorist nature then I think [the officer] should be asked to explain what sort of terrorist nature he thinks they are about and, if in any doubt, to call a supervisor.”

http://www.muslimnews.co.uk




Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Live!Facebook!Technorati!Spurl!Furl!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Readers have left 18 comments.
m: Quote

I am glad the police are doing their job..It seems the film crew were treated respectfully and sent on their way..They were not abused or taken into custody so what is the problem??
(1) 2008-06-02 10:52:24
markuk: Quote

You muslims absoloutly love it. I bet this producer was covered from head to toe aswell. If i was to go outside a mosque wearing a balaclaver taking photos. who do you think the first people would be the the imams would phone if they seen me?
(2) 2008-06-02 13:07:08
???: Quote

Markuk, if ever there was a stupid comment and a most distored one, I am going to give you the award for it.

Balaclaver? Honestly, is this the best you and (m): have to say? A kid can come out with a better angle, to justify both of your pathetic views.

At least, if you're going to give one, do it well.

Read the damn article. It says:

A Muslim TV producer has accused the police of constantly targeting her crew and stopping them from filming in the streets of London.

Do you see something there? The word is "CONSTANTLY TARGET."
(3) 2008-06-02 13:50:05
markuk: Quote

Well for as long as muslims CONSTANTLY threaten to TARGET the uk We need to police to CONSTANTLY be looking out. And if they aren't breaking the law then they should be happy our police our doing their job.
Why does it bother you that this person gets stopped a few times.
Let me ask you this. Why does it only bother you when the police stop muslims?
Some young people get stopped all the time.
(4) 2008-06-02 14:42:07
Gnim: Quote

As a Photography student, even my non Muslim friends have been stopped and searched, but only because they kept a beard, or wore that Arab scarf, which is raging on the street fashion today

However I think the police do need to be trained. Jumping someone because they have a camera or a tripod or are part of a media crew is something that needs more then just police right to accuse someone purely on cultural dress.

Certainly there is a grey area with a photographer, they have all rights to take street photographs, but the police need clear guidelines on what they see as suspicious, and that doesn’t and should never include someone who wears a scarf, or beard. This is why police are just being stupid about things. Muslim appearance = terrorist. It’s not that they are professionals doing a job.

In regards to an actual media crew, since when were they ever stopped and searched? It is evident it was because of her scarf and Muslim slightly terrorist origin.

There isn’t a grey area with a film crew, as they have the right papers, are professionals and can back up their work, where as photographers have a certain amount of freedom that police cannot infringe, therefore police act irrationally, because guidelines are not set. The guidelines do not state that and Muslim with a camera should be booked. If any born Brit supports this they must be utterly stupid.

Of course there have been Muslim terrorist; the above poster is just generalizing because the media has got him scared of all Muslims. Overall Police need to be trained on how to deal with this current issue.


(5) 2008-06-02 17:10:22
Lee: Quote

Well for as long as muslims CONSTANTLY threaten to TARGET the uk We need to police to CONSTANTLY be looking out. And if they aren't breaking the law then they should be happy our police our doing their job.
Why does it bother you that this person gets stopped a few times.
Let me ask you this. Why does it only bother you when the police stop muslims?
Some young people get stopped all the time.
— markuk
you words are like manure and runny at that.
(6) 2008-06-02 17:13:15
Wakey Wakey: Quote

Sorry, but if you go around dressed as 'Bat-Girls' up and down the streets of the Western world, what do you expect?

Think what the police in Saudi Arabia would do if two women in mini-skirts and low-cut tops (you know -- the sort that hypocritical Muslim men dream about from behind their silly beards)went around taking pictures! Oh, but stop, women probably arne't allowed to take pictures in that 'Islamic' country anyway.

I say to the Jilbaab girls: take a picture of yourself in a Jilbaab outside St.Paul's Cathedaral; now compare that with a picture of a girl in a bikini outside the Kaaba. Offensive? You bet.
(7) 2008-06-02 18:36:22
Colin: Quote

Talking of strange police behaviour, what are your readers' thoughts on members of the thin blue line stopping and questioning the two evangelists who were handing out Christian literature in so-called Muslim Birmingham? It sounds to me like they were on loan from the Saudi morality enforcement force.

If it's OK with the police for self-proclaimed representatives from the Religion of Peace to loudly proclaim on the streets that 'Bin Laden is on his way' what did the Christian evangelists do wrong? Too suspiciously peaceful perhaps?
(8) 2008-06-02 19:48:44
joe: Quote

meanwhile 2 Christians were threatened with violence for handing out leaflets in a "muslim no go area" in Birmingham by a "community support officer"!
(9) 2008-06-03 01:37:49
markuk: Quote

you words are like manure and runny at that.
Typical muslim reply
(10) 2008-06-03 13:08:54
shan: Quote

Its not a typical muslim reply,it is reply to typical non muslims bull manure.
people like you are blind to 300,000 so called christian terrorists committing thousands of acts of terror everyday in iraq but are quick to blame muslims when it comes to acts of terror in the u.k,everyday in iraq is 7/7 3 times or more yet you are blind to that fact.
we did not vote for ask anyone to bomb britain,yet millions voted for this government knowing what they were doing in iraq.
so instead of lecturing muslims get your fellow christians-atheists or pagans out of iraq and afghan then lecture us.
there was no terror threat before afghan and iraq manufactured or otherwise from the muslim community.
(11) 2008-06-03 13:49:07
markuk: Quote

The fact is im not a christian and the iraq has nothing at all to do with me. im not in iraq so any of you that want to go and help the iraqis fight the jihadists then go over there.
are you telling me the soldiers are strapping bombs to themselves and blowing people up every single day?
Tell me this Why didn't the Muslims from the uk go over to Iraq and try to blow up Saddam with a bomb strapped to you? I mean he did kill a lot of innocent Muslims.
Peaple blowing themselves up in london or america has nothing to do whatsoever wuth iraq.
what was the excuse for blowing up the world trade centre ? this was before iraq
What was the reason for the bali bombings?
Was this because of iraq or is there another excuse?
(12) 2008-06-03 18:55:28
William: Quote

"there was no terror threat before afghan and iraq manufactured or otherwise from the muslim community."

9/11 was before either. Try to keep up!
(13) 2008-06-04 09:13:02
shan: Quote

William practice what you preach,iraq and afghan were a decade or 2 before 911.
(14) 2008-06-04 10:34:45
markuk: Quote

What was the reason for islamists kidnapping girls and burning their faces in algeria. and killing tourists in egypt.
Also i want to point the way you are defending islam by giving explanations for why jihadists are doing this.
This is what happens with most muslims. They say they are against these evil people killing innocents but as soon as anyone mentions islam being a violent religion, then the same people who say these jihadists arent real muslims or this is nothing to do with islam, then go on to defend their actions by saying its because you are killing their brothers in iraq. Even though more muslims are killing everyone in iraq.
Is it logical to go to london and blow yourself up and kill dozens of people all of whome might have been against the iraq war? I you honestly believe these people are loving caring people but the iraq war made them want to kill anyone at all. They believe killing none muslims sends them to paradise.

Of course though none of my questions will you even dare to answer. All you will do is defend the jihadist with the iraq war.
(15) 2008-06-04 16:41:58
shan: Quote

Maybe you should ask yourself why you believe in lies and deceit.
iraq never attacked britain or america,today millions have been killed-maimed or made refugees.
so called christians in iraq have raped-sodomised-tortured to death-sexaully humiliate iraqis every day,this is a fact.
yet you cry hoarse over a allegation,anyone can make a allegation,but proving the allegation shows the veracity of its truthfulness.
(16) 2008-06-05 10:34:51
markuk: Quote

Its as though ive hit a raw nerve by calling the jihadists. so as usual you make up this story like a lot of muslims that the soldiers have gone to iraq to kill all the iraqi people. blowing everyone up with car bombs.So what about the rest of the violent jihad all over the world like burning girls faces in algeria in the name of islam or killing tourists in egypt? What has any of this got to do with the iraq war?
Do you truly believe that this is a logical response to the iraq war to go into london and blow up people who might have been as much against the iraq war as anyone.
Lets see if you answerr this then.
What if a gay person walked into a mosque in the uk and blew up every muslim and everyone said its because of the way iran treats gays and every time this happened this was used by every gay person as the excuse. Just admit it shan you hate the west with all your heart.
(17) 2008-06-05 12:20:32
shan: Quote

markuk the logical response is people do the crime so they do the time,not their parents-brothers or sister-uncles or aunties,their neighbours or their communities or their fellow beleivers.
so when you use the collective guilt logic then we shall use your same standards to describe the actions of so called christians-atheists or pagans.
If muslims of britain went to iran and helped kill gays then i would understand why he did what he did but i would not garee with it.
Hypocrites like yourselves use the same crap all the time,read the comments of muslim bloggers who have stated that no one be they individuals-groups or armies have the right to kill innocent civillians and those who do are terrorists.
guess what hypocrites like you never like to make such comments because according to racist bigots like yourselves,white christians can kill-rob-maim and torture millions but they are never terrorists.
I hate hypcorites and two faced liars who can see violent acts carried out by inviduals but not the daily acts of terror committed by 300,000 so called christians terrorists.
why should i hate my own country which is based in the west,my grandfather fought for my country and my father worked his back off for 40 years to put the great back into britain after world war two.
So please do not patrionise us .
Btw a asian community centre in cornwall was attacked,they left a pigfs head with the words leave now and painted a cross on the walls,the threat by so called christian extremists was obvious leave or die like pigs,you can check this on the BBC website.
(18) 2008-06-05 13:48:05
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.
 
Ireland Branch
Media Workshops

Search MPACUK.org

Recommended Books