Adverts/Promotions

CHL Properties When Slaves Become the Masters Journalism Diversity Fund Stop War On Iran

Disclaimer: MPACUK does not select these automated ads.


Subscribe to our newsletter:


"We Created Terror Among the Arabs" The Deir Yassin Massacre Print E-mail
Wednesday, 14 May 2008

israel_mt_hermon_israeli_flag.jpgOn April 9, 1948, members of the underground Jewish terrorist group, the Irgun, or IZL, led by Menachem Begin, who was to become the Israeli prime minister in 1977, entered the peaceful Arab village of Deir Yassin, massacred 250 men, women, children and the elderly, and stuffed many of the bodies down wells. There were also reports of rapes and mutilations. The Irgun was joined by the Jewish terrorist group, the Stern Gang, led by Yitzhak Shamir, who subsequently succeeded Begin as prime minister of Israel in the early '80s, and also by the Haganah, the militia under the control of David Ben Gurian. The Irgun, the Stern Gang and the Haganah later joined to form the Israeli Defense Force. Their tactics have not changed.

The massacre at Deir Yassin was widely publicized by the terrorists and the numerous heaped corpses displayed to the media. In Jaffe, which was at the time 98 percent Arab, as well as in other Arab communities, speaker trucks drove through the streets warning the population to flee and threatening another Deir Yassin. Begin said at the time, "We created terror among the Arabs and all the villages around. In one blow, we changed the strategic situation."

From about 1938 on to the founding of Israel, Begin was the leader of the Irgun. That group regularly assassinated English soldiers in Palestine and frequently hung their booby-trapped bodies in public places. Under Begin, the Irgun blew up the King David Hotel in Jerusalem in 1946, killing 97 British civil servants. The Stern Gang, under Shamir, also assassinated the U.N. representative to Palestine, Count Bernadotte, in 1948.

But Deir Yassin was not the only massacre by the Israeli Defense Force. That army, under Moshe Dayan, took the unarmed and undefended village of al-Dawazyma, located in the Hebron hills, massacred 80 to 100 of its residents, and threw their bodies into pits. "The children were killed by breaking their heads with sticks ... The remaining Arabs were then sealed in houses, as the village was systematically razed ..." (Nur Masalha, The Historical Roots of the Palestinian Refugee Question).

We read further. According to Yitzhak Rabin's biography:

We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Alon repeated his question: "What is to be done with the population?" BG waved his hand in a gesture, which said: Drive them out! ... I agreed that it was essential to drive the inhabitants out.

Continuing the narrative, Ben-Gurion University historian Benny Morris writes in "Operation Dani and the Palestinian Exodus from Lydda and Ramle in 1948", Middle East Journal, 40

At 13.30 hours on 12 July [1948]... Lieutenant-Colonel Yitzhak Rabin, operation Dani head Operation, issued the following order: '1. The inhabitants of Lydda must be expelled quickly without attention to age. They should be directed to Beit Nabala,... Implement Immediately.' A similar order was issued at the same time to the Kiryati Brigade concerning the inhabitants of the neighboring town of Ramle, occupied by Kiryati troops that morning... On 12 and 13 July, the Yaftah brigades carried out their orders, expelling the 50-60,000 remaining inhabitants of and refugees camped in and around the two towns....

About noon on 13 July, Operation Dani HQ informed IDF General Staff/Operations: 'Lydda police fort has been captured. [The troops] are busy expelling the inhabitants.... Lydda's inhabitants were forced to walk eastward to the Arab legion lines; many of Ramle's inhabitants were ferried in trucks or buses. Clogging the roads... the tens of thousands of refugees marched, gradually shedding their worldly goods along the way. It was a hot summer day. The Arab chroniclers, such as Sheikh Muhammed Nimr al Khatib, claimed that hundreds of children died in the march, from dehydration and disease. One Israeli witness described the spoor: the refugee column 'to begin with [jettisoned] utensils and furniture and, in the end, bodies of men, women, and children.

There were many other such villages with Arabic names that have almost been expunged from memory--but not quite. These facts have always been known to some historians, however they have been consistently denied by the official Israeli histories, as, indeed, Israel has never taken any responsibility for the exodus of Palestinians from the land of the present state of Israel.

Within the last 10 to 20 years, however, there has been an exponential increase in historical studies of the origins of the state of Israel which have coincided with the release by Israel of many, but not all, of the historical and military archives. Ben-Gurion University historian Benny Morris, as well as others, have systematically mined these documents and found numerous instances of massacres, and, by the way, not one shred of evidence for the frequently repeated official Israeli lie that the Palestinians fled Palestine because the surrounding Arab states told them to.

In fact, according to UN estimates, which some say are conservative, 750,000 Palestinians fled the site of the present Jewish state in 1948. Those refugees and their descendents now number about 4.5 million and constitute the largest and longest standing refugee population in the world. Many live in squalid refugee camps distributed in the surrounding Arab states or in the West Bank or Gaza, many retain the titles to their land, recognized by the British before 1948 or the Ottomans before that , and many retain the keys to their front doors of their former homes in what is now Israel, whether or not those doors still exists.

The '67 War generated a second wave of about 300,000 refugees from the West Bank and Gaza who were either expelled through direct or psychological methods or fled the Israel aerial attacks on the territories which included the extensive use of napalm.

The reader is invited to read the Hagana's Plan D , which has been available in English since the 1960s and was a military strategy of 1948 that entailed the evacuation of the Palestinian population from the areas of a future Jewish state.

Those who invoke the suicide bombings against mostly Israeli civilians to infer the righteousness of the Israeli cause live in a twilight of psychic denial of an otherwise unambiguous historical record: the state of Israel was founded on terrorism and ethnic cleansing.

The suicide bombings inside Israel, the first of which only occurred in 1994, after 25 years of occupation, is only a side show. That is a symptom and long way from the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

There will never be a solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict until Israel takes responsibility, under U.N. Resolution 194, calling for reparation of the Palestinian refugees, and recognizes the immense suffering it caused at that time. We need also to recognize the US is giving unqualified moral support to a state that is based on racial purity and one that is intrinsically expansionist.

William James Martin is a visiting Instructor of Mathematics at the University of Central Florida, Orlando. He can be reached at: martinw@email.unc.edu

 




Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Live!Facebook!Technorati!Spurl!Furl!Blogmarks!Yahoo!

Readers have left 16 comments.
Tahira: Quote

What is even more disgusting is the denial of these historic crimes by British Zionists today. This week the Zionist commentator Alex Brummer writing in the Jewish Chronicle referred to "the alleged massacre at Deir Yassin". That is as repugnant as Holocaust denial. But of course this denial is necessary if you want to 'celebrate' the founding of Israel - a state that was founded on the (continuing) ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people.
(1) 2008-05-15 08:36:43
RSD: Quote

This article does not concord with the studies conducted by Bir Zeit University. It repeats claims made by the Palestinian leadership in 1947 & 48 as part of their propoganda campaign, as acknowledged by Saeb Erekat and others. As in 1948 these inflated claims are absurd and ineffectual.
By all means accuse the Zionists of the crimes they have committed, but to fabricate or exagerate crimes that they have not committed simply polarises the communities and undermines the credibility of the real allagtions and complaints.
(2) 2008-05-15 08:41:21
Taz: Quote

This article does not concord with the studies conducted by Bir Zeit University. It repeats claims made by the Palestinian leadership in 1947 & 48 as part of their propoganda campaign, as acknowledged by Saeb Erekat and others. As in 1948 these inflated claims are absurd and ineffectual.
By all means accuse the Zionists of the crimes they have committed, but to fabricate or exagerate crimes that they have not committed simply polarises the communities and undermines the credibility of the real allagtions and complaints.
— RSD
Because Bir Zeit University is full of Zionist liars. Nothing new there.
(3) 2008-05-15 09:21:54
RSD: Quote

It comes as surprise to me that Bir Zeit is full of Zionist Liars, and I imagine an even greater surprise to the Zionists. Perhaps some more specific detail about this hotbed of Zionism in Palestine's foremost university would be useful. If Bir Zeit is a "Quisling" institution than perhaps MPACUK should be caling for its closure and warning people to neither attend it or support it.
(4) 2008-05-15 12:16:58
I Sidat: Quote

Want the truth go to someone who isn't a muslim, ask the people who know the middle east, askt the people who have been to the middle east and seen the Palestinian diaspora.

Why don't you search Noam Chomsky and find out the truth, buy/borrow his books and find out, rather ranting on about lies and denial of the reality.
(5) 2008-05-15 14:18:38
RSD: Quote

"I will keep here to advocacy in the serious sense: accompanied by some kind of feasible program of action, free from delusions about "acting on principle" without regard to "realism"—that is, without regard for the fate of suffering people." Noan Chomsky
I see no difference between Chomsky and myself on this issue. Palestinian and Israeli violence cannot deliver on either peace or a state so it is pointless. Palestinian violent political action has delivered nothing but more suffering for the Palestinian people. They are poorer now than at any time in the last 40 years, and getting poorer by the day.
(6) 2008-05-15 19:53:59
I Sidat: Quote

"I will keep here to advocacy in the serious sense: accompanied by some kind of feasible program of action, free from delusions about "acting on principle" without regard to "realism"—that is, without regard for the fate of suffering people." Noan Chomsky
— RSD


Firstly you don't understand what he is saying, and your missing a big chunk of wording/phrase/paragraphs here. Do you even know what he is actually saying here ? or have just copied and pasted?

Chomsky is one of the biggest critics of Israel so in no sense are you and him the same.
(7) 2008-05-16 02:07:30
Rob: Quote

RSD is in the same league as people who question the veracity of the holocaust,when they question they are called anti-semites.

There are people who will always deny the pain and suffering of the palestinian people as recognition means they are no longer victims but criminals themselves.
(8) 2008-05-16 11:39:18
Mohsin beg: Quote

AA

Failing to Plan, is planning for failure. They were strategic, they were organised, they were united, drived by strong leadership. They understood warfare psychology, they understood the tactics and strategies of modern business and warfare.

muslims, looking to become more Strategic, understand psychological leadership strategies,chek : the-empowerment-temple.com




(9) 2008-05-17 21:06:46
RSD: Quote

Rob,
I find your statement deeply offensive. To suggest that my comments have some equivalence to Holocaust Denial is absurd.
The point I have repeatedly made is that while exaggerationf or propoganda purposes is legimitate, it ceases to be legitimate if the overall objective is to find partnership for peace and to secure from the perpetrator of a crime their admission of guilt.
I think you will find that I have never denied that the Deir Yassin Massacre occurred. I have however insisted that it was used in an attempt by the Palestinian leadership to instill anger and the desire for revenge amongst the Palestinian Muslim and Christian populations. As is now acknowledged by the Palestinian leadership, this strategy backfired.
(10) 2008-05-19 08:57:35
Rob: Quote

RSD and how is that diffrent from jews using the holocaust to get political and monetary benbefits from europeans and others.

How is that diffrent from using the holocaust to get another peoples land and call them terrorist for resisting occupation.

Unless of course you suffer from the chosen ones syndrome,in which the suffering of jews matters but the suffering of others is lesser.
(11) 2008-05-19 11:10:04
RSD: Quote

Rob - You are of course right there would be no difference if anyone exaggerates their injuries to gain an advantage. It happens all the time with insurance claims - the downside is that we all end up paying for it.

I am far from certain that the various Jews as individuals and groups do gain significant monetary or political benefit out of the Holocaust. There is a lot of hype about it but I have yet to come across much real evidence. (But I guess the same could be said of the African Diaspora and Slavery / Colonialism) Some countries have decided to make restitution to them as victims of the Nazis or the collaborationist regimes under Nazi occupation. But this is not universal. Those Jews seeking specific restitution for their financial / material losses have had to go through lengthy and often tortuous court cases. Consider it took Swiss and British banks 5 decades to get round to admitting that they had grabbed the money of Jewish victims, and then be compelled to hand it back. In the Frank Singer case it took from 1945 to 1980 to get his German citizenship back, even though he had resided in the same house in Cologne for his entire life.

My personal hope is that peace can come about in the Middle East and a peace where everyone can contribute to and share in prosperity. This wil not come about until every community there admits to their own wrong doing. Currently there is exaggeration piled upon exaggeration. This simply serves to drive the sides further and further apart and undermines any hope for a better future. Sadly an attempt by the PeaceNet about 10 years ago to progress dialogue for peace by owning up to wrong doing collapsed when the Jewish Israelis acknowledged Deir Yassin hoping that their Palestinian counterparts would reciprocate with perhaps the Hebron or Jerusalem massacres. It became a bile-filled feeding frenzy that portrayed all Israeli Jews as mass murderers and denied any Palestinian wrong doing. The Israelis walked away undermined and dismayed, and to date there has been no other inter-communal attempt at ending the anger between them.
(12) 2008-05-19 19:44:38
Rob: Quote

RSD peace can only come in palestine when everyone is treated equally .

personally i have stated the best solution as being one nation for all.
(13) 2008-05-20 17:50:33
RSD: Quote

Rob, the reformation of the original Palestinian mandate territory stretching from the Mediterrenean to the Iraqi border may be a wonderful ideal. However the proponents of the single state never explain how this could be achieved in a peaceful manner.
The complexity of how Israel, "Palestine" and Jordan could be integrated into a single nation state is bewildering. Each has its own very different legal system, education system, defence system, and so on. If there is to be a single state which of the 3 constitutions becomes the constution for all 3? What would be the claims upon state properties of the 3 political entities? Would El-Al or ZIM as nationalised Israeli / Zionist enterprises automatically become part of a commonwealth where the majority have made no investment into these businesses? How would the various defnce forces be integrated, and would promotion to command be purely on merit? The qeustions go on and on, and I have yet to hear a sensible answer to any of them. Enforce union would undoubtedly result in civil war in which unfortunately the Palestinians would find themselves sandwiched between Israeli & Jordanian forces that would destroy them - do never overlook the emnity that the Hashemite Bedouin direct towards the Palestinians.
(14) 2008-05-21 12:09:14
Rob: Quote

RSD the point about one nation is hard if the intention is not to have a one state for all.

As th saying goes where there is a will there is a way.

The law of the land shall be secular for those who wish to be judged by that criterion and relgious for those who wish to be judged by relgious law.

The choice will be the victim and his families in criminal cases.

The political system shall be P.R representation so everyones say shall be heard.

The armny shall be recruited based on P.R and will defend the nation.
(15) 2008-05-21 17:38:09
RSD: Quote

Rob, The problem is foresee, other than no one is prepared to compromise, is that if there is a dual legal system secular / religious and selction is determined by the victim, then it must be questionable whether the trials involving people of different religions would be fair. Jewish and Islamic jurisprudence have distinctive precidences which may not be acceptable to someone not from that faith. As much as the victim is entitled to justice, so is the alleged perpetrator of a crime.
IMO a federation between the 3 nations with the objective creating a single economic entity, similar to the Benelux arrangement, is the most likely to succeed and most likely to have a beneficial outcome for all. In respect of the defence forces it is imperitive that they are subordinate to the head of state, and not to a political party, and that promotion is based solely upon merit.
However tio create such a federation or even single nation state would be an enormous threat to the regimes in the region and would face immediate threat and disruption.
(16) 2008-05-23 10:15:17
The author or administrator has closed this item for comments.
 
MPACUK Media Workshops

Search MPACUK.org

Recommended Books