In so many words she says that All paletinians are responsible so they should all be collectively punished.

Melanie is trying to justify war crimes committed by Israel. Where do her loyalties lie? With Britain who would like to see peace in the Middle East or with Israel who would like to continue waging war crimes and getting away with it.

I think everyone on the panel was disgusted with her views.

Should someone with such extreme views be allowed to influence the minds of British citizens through such a high platform in the media?

I think she should be sacked from her job in the Daily Mail for supporting and advocating war crimes. If a Muslim can be sacked from the Guardian for having strong views then why can't Melanie be sacked from the Daily Mail?

melanie won't be sacked by The daily mail, as the paper is owned by her brethren the Zionists.

Ditto for BBC and the rest of the so called mainstream media.

How else would the would the world believe the fairytale lies of 9/11 and 7/7.

thanks MPAC for noting Phillips' inflammatory ideas. but Mike O' Brian might not be entirely correct. Phillips' new book on 77, "Londonistan", is a bestseller; it fluctuates within the top 100 on Amazon, and apart from being backed by a popular newspaper the Daily Mail, she also gets decent access to national TV. compare that to me; i'm also the author of a 77 book ("The London Bombings: An Independent Inquiry" www.independent inquiry.co.uk), which despite being featured well in the Sunday Times and Independent on Sunday, is being ignored by the media, and blacked out by radio and tv. my book challenges the govt's account of the 77 attacks (and more), exposes uk intelligence connections with terrorists, and documents how western powers are still using elements of al-Qaeda today. this is information that the public needs to know, but it doesn't get a hearing. we need to discredit and counteract people and ideas like that of Melanie Phillips using solid information. modestly, i suggest that my book is at least a starting point...

Melanie Philips speaks for the indiginous British Subject . It is not necessary for us to defend her , she does the job more eloquently than most . But it is most notable the way you Anti British , Anti Western Lemmings attempt , as in all your diatribes , to demonise her , rather than the views she espouses . Just as 80% of muslims believe suicide bombers are martyrs , so 90% of the majority, British Subjects believe they are languishing in HELL and feel fortunate that they are no longer residing on this planet .

I happen to agree with everything that Melanie said. Israel has a right to protect itself against a genocidal project in the same way as the British or French do. I'd say he views were pretty mainstream.

It’s disgusting what she said! How can BBC even allow a warmonger to be amongst the panellists, knowing her xenophobic attitude towards an issue, which is so delicate… She really needs to set her priorities straight, if she wants to be true patriotic British citizen then she should denounce using war crime as her resolution to making peace, we’re ashamed of having such people in our country!

The British people cannot be with this fifth columnist, its agenda is genocide of the world, it has nothing but hate for the free world especially rthe actual indigenous population. It has a israel first, UK & the West second as so many genocidal projects seen before, be it WW1 & 2, Apartheid regime with its fundamentalist hate of free speech by censoring facts & replace it with its own agenda. Just like maxwell or j king the fundamentalists who are living in israel at the cost of the West, especially the free world. Being a disloyal "race" that has crawled to this poisonous position by continuing the ”newspapers” origins that openly supported fascism & was photographed with Hitler. The replies again show a utter lack of the ability to read ENGLISH as the article clearly espouses her views.. Settlers are by definition murderers & deserve far worse than they have done since the world has the right by human & international law to retaliate, thus protecting itself. Especially from the false flag attacks which are a hallmark of the fifth column.indigenous IS THE WRONG SPELLING it is indigenous, no wonder with your lack of education & speaking a sewer version of GERMAN.

You just can't stand anyone who has a different opinion or who disagreed with you. If only you put as much energy into getting your own house in order.

Constructive debate, tolerance and understanding, sharing of different views, humility and recognising the plethora of opinions people have is what it's all about not blaming others, inciting hatred and pretending you're integrated and you accept the British way of life by posting England world cup updates on your website.

i wonder what melanies would say if asked if the deliberate targetting of civilians was terrorism?

i suspect she would hyperventilate and not be able to answer with a simple yes.

the difficulty philips has is that she doesnt see the extremism in her diatribes, this is true of most pro zionists who are so indoctrinated in hate that the objective viewpoint cannot be made.

does melanie ever accept any israeli wrongdoing?

would she accept that israel was created through terrorism even though other peaceful options were available and some of that terrorist leadership became leaders of israel.

are we now to blame israels people for their voting for terrorists?

why do the likes of philips deny the same right of passage that israel has taken for itself?

I cannot fault Melanie's reasoning. I'll never forget the sight of dancing in the streets of Gaza as seventeen crazed Saudi muslims brought the twin towers crashing down in New York. Can anyone update me as to whether or not there was more of the same there last July 7?

zionism has nothing to do with this or the West, is as indigenous as the nazis were to the White psyche. The daily use of the word 'diatribe' shows the lack of English skills & grammar since this foreign "reporter" is bringing the UK & the Whites into disrepute with its actual genocidal project called israel. So what loyalty has this newspaper - none. Considering the zionists were in complete agreement with the nazis & it is common knowledge that the daily mail supported the black shirts, we Whites have had enough of the daily whining & pretend loyalty with constant excuses of what it is like in this country show that lack of any factual substance about the foreign controlled press in the UK. It has its own racial agenda to cause the MAX pain & mistreatment to the life of the actual Western citizen. We are lucky to see the mass murderers that are sitting home in Hades when the loyal UK population gets its revenge, then this & the West will be zionist free. The world then will be protected against this hate speech & action. Thus no more false flag attacks

mad mel is well and truly mad. day by day she is making herself look like a complete lunatic

Zionist like Melanie do not and NEVER will speak for the indiginous population. She and her Zionist cronies speak only for Zionism.

The Zionists are hell bent on taking over the globe- nay they have nearly done it.

It is the ideology of Zionism that hides behind elequent words yet in reality it is they who commit the most vile acts.

It is the Zionists and their masonic co- conspirists that are the blot on human kind.

Remember that melanie is justifing murder of a defencless race and esp the targetting of children and infants.

The British are against that thankyou.

PS Also some of us Brits know what False Flag means.

Phillips is a Zionist witch. She does not care about the suffering of the Palestinians. She pretends that her loyalty lies in London but we all know it actually lies in Tel Aviv. Melanie Phillips is as English as a bagel.

Melanie is a 5th coloumn of Israel in Britain. She fly's the British flag as a cover only to push this beloved country into a war for her true master - israel.

Colin, I think you'd be surprised, that was a set up. Take a look at the following website:http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/fiveisraelis.htmlAnd here's the conclusion on this:1. The Israeli "movers" cheered the 9-11 attacks to celebrate the successful accomplishment of the greatest spy operation ever pulled off in history.2. One of them, or an accomplice, then calls a 9-1-1 police dispatcher to report Palestinian bomb-makers in a white van headed for the Holland Tunnel.3. Having thus pre-framed the Palestinians with this phone call, the Israeli bombers then head for the George Washington Bridge instead, where they will drop off their time-bomb van and escape with Urban Moving accomplices.4. But the police react very wisely and proactively by closing off ALL bridges and tunnels instead of just the Holland Tunnel. This move inadvertently foils the Israelis' misdirection play and leads to their own capture and 40 day torture.5. To cover up this story, the U.S. Justice Department rounds up over 1000 Arabs for minor immigration violations and places them in New York area jails.The Israelis therefore become less conspicuous as the government and media can now claim that the Israelis were just immigration violators caught in the same dragnet as many other Arabs.6. After several months, FBI and Justice Department "higher-ups" are able to gradually push aside the local FBI agents and free the Israelis quietlyAnd..Now, did Bin Ladden hit weltrade centre? Here's something the Media and M.Philips won't tell you. These are the words of Osama Bin Laddin:But bin Laden strongly denied any role in the attacks and suggested that Zionists orchestrated the 9-11 attacks. The BBC published bin Laden's statement of denial in which he said:"I was not involved in the September 11 attacks in the United States nor did I have knowledge of the attacks. There exists a government within a government within the United States. The United States should try to trace the perpetrators of these attacks within itself; to the people who want to make the present century a century of conflict between Islam and Christianity. That secret government must be asked as to who carried out the attacks. ... The American system is totally in control of the Jews, whose first priority is Israel, not the United States." (26)You never heard that quote on your nightly newscast did you?Between the time of its publication and October 7, the US apparently spent its time creating a fake "bin Laden" interview, using either a stand-in or morphing. Or was the fraud produced by the Brits, as a favor to the US? No, the Taliban Home Video was a ham-fisted effort. The Brits usually have more subtlety. Som Muslims jumping up for joy? No Colin. Mossad spies, jumping up for joy. And I realised now, people just don't do enough THINKING and research to figure out, all this, especially Phillips, is leading to one big mess in UK. That's what she wants. That's what the Zionists wants!

(26) http://www.public-action.com/911/oblintrv.html

Go out in the street and converse with the real British Subjects . Then see what the indiginous population believe , not the rabid indoctrinated claptrap written about 5th columns ? zionists ? and the anti muslim media . Whats to stop you starting your own newspaper espousing your own values , other than the fact that just like this bigotted , joke of a web site , no FREE THINKING unbiased person takes it`s ideas seriously and would never stoop to wasting time reading such indoctrinated rubbish other than to observe how low , backward and vile your values have become . The more BRITISH SUBJECTS that write in to expose your Anti British , Anti Western doctrines the better .

Another British subject are you really Melanie, because you sound as mad as her? I’m a white non-Muslim British citizen, and I am afraid I must disagree with you. People like her are borderline racists and do seem to have an agenda on behalf of Israel and not Britain. Those who wish our great land to wage war for a foreign power will not dupe those who love Britain.

I have just received a totally bonkers email from one of your commentators claiming that 9/11 was an Israeli secret service job, with an equally barking 'interview' with Bin Laden on the Waco (well named!) News Service to suppot the claim.
Does anyone know if the Israeli secret service had a cell operating in Leeds last July? Maybo Waco NS does.

Colin, if the 911 was bonkers information, then answer back with facts the way the comment gave facts. Bush said, "We never would have thought, plans would ever crash in weltrade centre." That was said in front of reporters on CNN news.

Guess what? I got documents, clips, which says:

1. 4 years before prior to 911, the usa fighter planes have been practising a secenerio of "just in case planes hit the WelTrade centre."

2. When a proffesional golfer flew his plane out of the zone, 10 planes, in a matter of 10 mins surrounded him and called him to back off.

How come, a bloody jumbo jets, couldn't be detected? USA is the most powerful country, with the most sophisticated tool.

3. It was an inside job, explosives. Now you may say, "how come there was security and no noticed them."

Here is what happpened colin. A financial anyalst who worked in the trade centre told the People's Magazine, that in the weeks before 9/11, that there were unannouced and unusual drills.

Both the twin towers and building 7 was evacuated for..security reasons.

4. Daria Cord, a security worked 12 hours shifts for two weeks because...NUMEROUS PHONE THREATS. But on Thursday THE 6TH, Bomb Sniffing dogs were abruptly removed.

Who authorised this:

- President Bush's brother - Marvin. Was Board of directors of Securicom from 1993 till fiscal year 200.

Wait for it. Securicom now known as STRATASEC, an electronic and security company backed by Kuwaite and American Corporation.

which PROVIDED SECIRITY FOR - UNITED AIRLINES, Dallas Interntaional Airport, and from the early 1990's upto the day of 9/11...THE....WELTRADE..CENTRE.

Marvin Bush is also the former director of FCC Insurance Holdings which...wait for it...insured part of the Weltrade Centre on 9/11.

More information on this was suppose to be disclosed but never was. Today the FCC has not revealed what they've learnt. And people need to know.

Now...evidence, regarding the remains. What stupid, moron of either police, of intelligence would ever consider getting rid of the evidence, the remains of debris????

Here's what happened Colin. Dispute this till you go red in the face. It's a fact and evidence is nearby to shut anyone up.

If onl;y we could examine the debri from the Weltrade Centre and figure out what happened.

Mayor Julianie began shipping the remain to recycling yards overseas, before investigators could even examine it. They blocked off the crime scene and DESTROYED all the evidence.

Guess who was allowed into the site? Controlled Demolition who were also responsible for cleaning up after the Okloham bombing in 1995.

The weltrade centre, everything, from the planes hitting, to the planning, to the ridding of evidence, was all done with Military Precision.

WHY? Do your homework, or shall I do it for you and type it here?

Forgot to say Colin and for any Zionist and usa officials. A film has been made, and dissaprove through evidence, what is the documentary made which is called THE TRUTH & LIES OF 9/11, This pioneering, groundbreaking expose of 9-11.NONE as yet as come forward. Not even the CIA. So come forward. £1000 is ready for you to dispute the authenticity of the evidence. And admittance in front the world...you are right. None I say has come forward since the making of the film.

Melanie Phillips is not British. She refuses to answer the question as to who she would support of there was a war between Britain and the Jewish State. Her loyalties definitely lie elsewhere which begs the question of why the heck she doesn't just leave this country and go back to her 'homeland' if it's so awful here for her. Boo hoo.