| Kidnapped: 1 Israeli 9,032 Palestinians |
|
|
| Wednesday, 28 June 2006 | ||
|
For Walid al-Houdaly, 46, the capture of an Israeli soldier by Palestinian militants offers the opportunity that his wife and their 18-month-old child will be freed from prison.
The Palestinian militant factions who kidnapped Cpl Gilad Shalit on Sunday - including the Izzedine al-Qassam Brigades, the military wing of the ruling Hamas party - have called for the release of all Palestinian women and children held in Israeli prisons in return for news on the missing soldier. Israel is believed to have about 100 women and 300 under-18s among the more than 8,000 Palestinian prisoners in its jails.
Like many Palestinians, Mr Houdaly believes that the world is focussing on the fate of one Israeli soldier when thousands of Palestinians have been imprisoned or detained in what they regard as their fight for independence. "There is one soldier, but there have been hundreds of Palestinians kidnapped from their houses," says the writer, referring in part to his wife who he says was dragged from their Ramallah home by Israeli soldiers early one morning. "If the world protests about the kidnapping of one soldier, why don't they protest about the Palestinians that have been kidnapped in the last 10 years," Mr Houdaly adds, sitting in his Ramallah office with books scattered across his desk. 'Without charge' Mr Houdaly says his wife, Ataf, 44, headed a women's organisation dedicated to providing health services for poor Palestinians. But for the last seven months, Mr Houdaly says, she has been held in Israeli prison under administration detention - imprisonment without charge. PALESTINIANS IN ISRAELI DETENTION
3,111 held by Israeli army, 741 in administrative detention (without trial)
5,127 held in Israeli prisons, 53 in administrative detention
Source: B'Tselem, January 2006 The mother went on a 16-day hunger strike before the Israeli prison authorities allowed her baby Aesha to be brought to stay with her, in the jail, Mr Houdaly says. It is women and children such as Ataf and Aesha that the militant factions would like to see released. But the Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has warned that Israel would not allow itself to become the victim of "Hamas' terrorist blackmail". "The question of freeing [Palestinian] prisoners is in no way on the Israeli government agenda," Mr Olmert said during a speech in Jerusalem. "There will be no negotiations, no bargaining, no agreements." History of exchanges But the kidnapping of Israeli soldiers in return for the release of Palestinians is nothing new. Israel has always vowed to bring home its soldiers and civilians, whether dead or alive, making kidnapping a top priority for many its enemies. In 2004, Israel released 429 Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners and returned the bodies of 59 in return for the release of one Israeli and the bodies of three of its dead. But Palestinian militants have rarely been successful in kidnapping Israeli soldiers. The last time was in 1994, when Palestinian militants seized 19-year-old Arial Nachson. The soldier was killed with his three captors during a rescue operation by Israeli Special Forces. Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails are an emotive issue for the majority of families in the occupied Palestinian territories, says George Jiacaman, a political science professor at the West Bank's Birzeit University. "Since the political process between the Palestinians and the Israelis is dead, many Palestinians think that the only way to get prisoners from jail is through some kind of exchange," he says. Mr Houdaly knows more than most about imprisonment. Apart from his wife, Mr Houdaly was himself jailed for 12 years for being a political organiser. He has also written a non-fiction book The Grave of Lives, documenting the experiences of some Palestinian prisoners. More than most Mr Houdaly wants his wife and daughter to return to his home - and Cpl Shalit to return to his family.
By Martin Patience
Story from BBC NEWS: Readers have left 14 comments.
Hanan Fadali:
Quote
Salamoalaiykom everyone. Just want to let you know the latest breaking news, am watching the news and Israel have just begun the launch in the middle of the night on Gaza to recover the soldier. No doubt that in the search for this one soldier, hundreds of Palestinians will die. Also France, US and many others are putting pressure on the kidnappers to release the captive. CAN U BELIEVE THIS??? international outcry over ONE soldier and yet thousands of Palis die and nobody bats an eyelid...this is what is known as Western hypocrisy and Arab apathy. SHAME ON THEM!!! SHAME SHAME SHAME! and of course CNN are reporting a VERY biased one-sided story.
(1)
2006-06-28 01:09:11
Ash:
Quote
Here we again! DOUBLE STANDARDS!!
ONE SOLDIER! and there are over 12,000 palestinian political prisioners being held in israeli prisons, including 400 women and 150 of their children. Where is the international condemnation??? If the Palestinians recact like Israel to free their people, they are labelled as "militants" Don't forget that the US-led political and economic blokade still continues. In gaza the sources of supply have now been bombed, including 3 bridges which link the north and south, (so now no ambulances, fire engines or and sort of transport facilities can pass). Also the power supply has been cut off which catered for over a milion. All this for ONE! So Israel is intensifying situation further! The soldier will surely be killed with this sort of behaviour.
(2)
2006-06-28 12:50:36
Bilal Patel:
Quote
Simple solution: If the Jews kill one Arab, then one Jewish soldier dies.
(3)
2006-06-28 16:27:06
Taz:
Quote
The real issue is not one captured Israeli fascist-army killer but the fact that Israel is jailing women and CHILDREN. A pure scum state that needs to be made to comply with international standards instead of carrying on its apartheid policies with impunity.
(4)
2006-06-28 17:34:46
old news:
Quote
Remember during the Apartheid / zionazi regime a saying among the free world "one settler one bullet".
Applies here just fine.
(5)
2006-06-28 20:34:25
Edwin:
Quote
Many Pali mothers will be weeping before we get thru with you...
(6)
2006-06-28 21:03:15
hussein:
Quote
salaam
the first message says shame on them , and it is completely correct, these poor people are being treated worse than animals by these israeli terrorists. i also believe it is shame on me because i am doing nothing to stop it. i may not be very clever and i have no idea other than charity to help the palestinians, i ask someone reading or mpac to please give me some actions i can take to help the oppressed people.
(7)
2006-06-28 22:18:35
aa:
Quote
To Edwin
And what makes you different from Hitler then you murderous racist? You get glee from the killing of innocent Muslims. Who's next christians. The world should know of the threat of the real extremists: Zionists.
(8)
2006-06-29 09:19:03
Africana:
Quote
The psycho state thinks that sneaking in the middle of night, blowing up electric power stations, poisoning water, killing babies & women, ripping open the belly of pregnant women, killing old women and men and horrors upon horrors like this: committing war crimes is awesome power. It is a thug+goon+terrorist state.
The US, UK and the lovers of terrorism will always veto any decent & honest resolution in the dictatorial, despotic security council/Annan’s get rich family project. The security council is the first group that should be eliminated and stripped of their “support of Israeli terrorism”. These despots and thugs have audacity to lecture about democracy and civilization. I haven’t elected or voted for my leader so that he can endanger my life for his lust of IsraHelli butchery and barbarity. If they love it so much, let them they offer themselves and their families.
(9)
2006-06-29 16:14:06
easy peasy:
Quote
A simpe solution, every Human a zionist murders, the Human race does the same back to them.
(10)
2006-06-29 17:09:09
Ben:
Quote
Feuds are hardly ever so simple, where one side is the good guy and the other the bad. Depending on who your sources are, Israel may not be justly imprisoning every palestinian they have captive, but certainly women and children are being used to attack and are involved in the killings of Jews as well. As for the U.S. and other allies, it should at least be understandable to not side with people that call for your destruction and commit terrorist acts against your people. And please, some of the U.S. hating really makes you wonder, "why don't you leave?" Again, the flip side being that Palestinians and Arabs in general are getting hard hit because of the few that commit terrorist attacks, but we really do need to take into account how spin affects our news, no matter what side you're on. Unless someone wipes out the other, we're gonna need to find real solutions, other than trying to justify either side's "shameful acts".
(11)
2006-06-29 20:15:41
Marcia:
Quote
Lets get some facts, I assume you are White, probably an israeli, me I am White & see the world as it is. Since the "Western" media reports what it is told, its reporters are mostly non Christian, thus they report things for their own gain, be it with a smile over a dead baby or disinformation. This is true for the "terrorist" angle since Arabs are the bogey men like Jews were last century, but this Anti Semitic attitude against the Jesus people in Palestine came before WW2 & the nazis. So the world sees it as I have just said, especially as your lot who hates this & other sites should leave.
(12)
2006-06-29 20:51:00
Ben:
Quote
Marcia, I'm not sure if you're responding to my comment, but in case you are, you might want to be more cautious with your jumping to conclusions. I am not White, I am Asian. I have no "personal stake" in this, and especially not one of hatred towards one party or another. I don't think Israel has done everything "right", but I certainly don't think Palestine has clean hands either. This is not to say, "well, we are all human, so let's just deal with hating each other." No, I would rather hope that we raise our standards, not just for our "enemies" but for ourselves as well. As for another of your false conclusions (if indeed your comment was directed towards me), I don't hate this site. Why would I hate this site? I cringe at many of the comments and articles, but if I only "narrowed" my news sources to those that favored Israel, wouldn't I just be guilty of the media blindness you accuse of? Hopefully you are all reading from various sources as well, and not just "sites like these".
(13)
2006-07-05 19:19:39
Daermon:
Quote
Taz, Husein, and Ben...you three seem to be the only voices of intellect here...
bravo to you to the rest... you CANNOT cause peace by war...5000+ years of history shows us this... in over 2000 of those years the middle east has been an a semi static state of war with itself...where has this gotten them....more bullets does not solve the problem zion is not to blame, neither is allah, yaweh, buddha, black, white, christian, muslim, jew, or any other simply put humanity is to blame...one and all, and till our species grows up a bit this will continue... care to try to rebuff that statement? to justify the killing of innocents and children on ALL sides?.....just try to justify such a thing...show us how foolish you are.
(14)
2006-07-25 09:24:25
|
||









